🎧 Listen to the Discussion(two hosts talk through their thoughts on this article)
This is an AI-generated audio overview of this article, created with Google NotebookLM. Two hosts discuss the article together, sharing their own thoughts and commentary — it is not a reading of the article text.
In my recent article on putting the garden to bed for winter, I wrote that I had planted 120 cloves of garlic. Afterwards I found myself asking again, "Why does a household of two need as many as 120?" The answer lies in the black garlic that my wife and I eat every morning. In this article I set out eight questions that a reader might ask, and I answer them one by one.
Why do I plant as many as 120 cloves of garlic?
About ten years ago, on a shelf at Waitrose, the British supermarket, I found an unfamiliar food called black garlic. I bought some to try, and I still remember how moved I was when I ate one clove and thought, what a delicious thing this is. This was because it had the shape of garlic but no heat at all, and it was sweet and sticky like dried fruit.
This is the black garlic I make myself. The skin turns amber and the flesh inside turns black.
The jar behind once held the black garlic I used to buy, and I now use it for storage.
Since then I have eaten five cloves every morning with breakfast, and my wife, who is smaller than I am, eats three. However, black garlic in the shops costs about £10 for 150 g of peeled cloves. That is expensive for two people to eat every morning, so about five years ago I decided to make it myself.
Once you make it yourself, you need a great deal of raw garlic. If one bulb holds about ten cloves, the 20 bulbs that I use each time come to about 200 cloves. The two of us eat eight cloves a day, so 200 cloves are gone in about 25 days. To cover our half-year in Britain, about 180 days, with black garlic, the calculation comes to 1,440 cloves, or about 144 bulbs, and about seven runs of the machine. That is why what I grow in the garden is gone before I know it. The number 120 was not the result of careful calculation, but a figure I settled on from years of experience, thinking that this many should be enough.
Usually I keep back some of the garlic from the garden to plant the following year. This year, though, the bulbs were too small to use as seed, so I gave them to the kitchen and planted large cloves from supermarket garlic instead.
Here is the kind of peeled black garlic I used to buy.
The Original Black Garlic Peeled Cloves (150 g)
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
Why does white garlic turn black and sweet?
My machine has the words "BLACK GARLIC FERMENTER" printed on it. Yet when I looked into it, I learned that what turns garlic black is not the work of microbes, as it is with natto or miso. What turns it black is the Maillard reaction, in which sugars and amino acids join together under heat.
The Maillard reaction was reported in 1912 by the French chemist Louis Camille Maillard, and it gives us the brown crust of bread, the savoury smell of roasted meat, and the dark colour of miso and soy sauce. In the kitchen it normally happens within minutes at a high temperature. With black garlic it proceeds slowly, over many days or weeks, at a much lower temperature of about 60–90°C and in high humidity (a 2021 review of the compounds and making of black garlic).
Natto is fermented soya beans and miso is fermented soya bean paste; both are everyday Japanese foods made with the help of microbes.
Then why do the heat and the smell disappear? The source of the sharp heat and smell of raw garlic is a compound called allicin. Allicin is formed for the first time, by the action of an enzyme, from a compound called alliin when garlic is cut or crushed. When whole bulbs are kept warm for a long time, however, the alliin itself, the source of allicin, is changed by the heat into other compounds, so both the heat and the smell grow weaker.
The reason for the sweetness also lies in the heat. The long chains of sugar that garlic stores are cut short by the heat and become sugars that the tongue tastes as sweet. At the same time, a compound called S-allyl cysteine, of which raw garlic has only a little, is known to increase.
How white garlic changes in my machine until it turns black. The heat and smell decrease, and the sweetness increases.
This is a simplified diagram, drawn to make the size of the change easy to see.
There was one more thing that surprised me as I read. Black garlic is not a traditional food from long ago, but a new food that has spread only in the last twenty years or so. According to a document from the Tohoku Bureau of Japan's Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry (Japanese language), it began in Mie Prefecture, and in Aomori Prefecture research and development moved forward in 2006, prompted by the published research of Dr Jin-ichi Sasaki, a former professor at Hirosaki University's medical school. The Tohoku office of Japan's Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries (Japanese language) also explains that black garlic is made by leaving white garlic in high heat and humidity for three to four weeks.
Aomori, at the northern tip of Japan's main island, grows most of the country's garlic; Mie is a prefecture in central Japan.
For anyone who wants to know more about the chemistry that happens in the kitchen, this book is a reliable guide.
On Food and Cooking: The Science and Lore of the Kitchen, by Harold McGee
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
Is glycation the same as ageing, and does burnt food cause cancer?
Here I will write about something that made me, at 66, stop and think. The Maillard reaction is in fact also going on slowly inside our own bodies, at body temperature. Inside the body this reaction is called glycation.
The figure that brings glycation close to home is HbA1c, which we see in health checks. HbA1c shows what share of haemoglobin, a protein inside the red blood cells, has joined with sugar. Red blood cells live for two to three months, so this figure reflects the average blood sugar of the past two to three months, as Diabetes UK explains. Unlike a blood sugar reading, which goes up and down with the previous day's meals, it is a figure like a school report that shows how we have lived over several months.
Then how should we read our state of health from this figure? Diabetes UK advises people who have been told they are at risk of diabetes to aim for below 42 mmol/mol (6.0%), and people who already have diabetes to take 48 mmol/mol (6.5%) or below as the ideal guide. In Japan, 6.5% or above is judged to be the "diabetic type" (Kenko Choju Net of the Japan Foundation for Aging and Health, Japanese language), and in the national health check 5.6% is the line at which people are advised to review their way of living. However, the figure may not come out correctly when there is an illness that affects the red blood cells, such as anaemia, so it is a figure to follow over time with a doctor and not one to judge from a single reading.
People sometimes say that "glycation is ageing itself". When I gathered the general view, I took it that half of this is certain and half goes too far. What is regarded as certain is that substances called AGEs (advanced glycation end products), which form when glycation has gone further, are involved in the ageing of the skin (a 2024 review of AGEs and the skin). This is because the longer a protein stays in the body without being replaced, like the collagen that keeps the skin firm, the longer it has to join with sugar.
Yet it has not been settled whether glycation is a "cause" of ageing or "one" of the many changes that come with ageing. This is because many other mechanisms are also involved in ageing. I also could not find any high-quality research confirming that foods or supplements sold as "anti-glycation" slow human ageing. What can be said for now is that not leaving blood sugar high is thought to be the basis for keeping glycation from going too far.
The old saying that "burnt food causes cancer", which we have long heard, is in fact also connected with the same reaction. When foods rich in starch, such as potatoes and bread, are baked or fried at 120°C or above, a substance called acrylamide is formed in the course of the Maillard reaction (explanation by Japan's Ministry of Agriculture, Forestry and Fisheries, Japanese language). Acrylamide has been linked with cancer in animal experiments, but in people no clear and consistent link has been found between the amount taken in from food and cancer. Cancer Research UK also explains that there is no need to panic because the morning toast was burnt, and that smoking, obesity and alcohol are far bigger factors. In Japan, too, the "New Twelve Rules for Preventing Cancer" revised in 2011 (Japanese language) have no item about avoiding burnt food.
Then is black garlic "burnt"? Black garlic is not something that has been blackened by burning. The temperature is far below 120°C and the reaction proceeds while the moisture is kept in, so it comes about in a different way from the burnt part of toast. However, it has also been reported that some of the compounds formed by the Maillard reaction increase the longer the heating goes on (a study of a compound called 5-HMF in black garlic). The same study also reports that the amount eaten in the ordinary way is at a level that raises no safety concern, but black garlic is not something that gets better the longer it is left.
This means that the human body moves little by little, over decades, through a change that garlic passes through in a few days. When I was young, I thought of ageing as nothing but decline. Yet as I watch the same reaction give garlic its sweetness and deep colour each time, I feel that changing over time brings not only things that are lost but also things that are added. Of course, this is only how I feel, and I am not saying that eating black garlic can prevent glycation in the body.
How do I make it?
The method is so simple that it is almost a disappointment. I use a machine made only for black garlic, and the one I use now is my third.
The black garlic machine that I keep in the garage.
I only press the "Garlic" button, and the machine holds the temperature for me.
I do not wash the garlic or peel it, and I put it in as whole bulbs. The wire rack inside has two levels, and I place ten bulbs on each level, twenty in all.
The machine with its lid open. I place whole bulbs of garlic, with their skins on, on this wire rack.
Ten bulbs on each level and twenty on two levels make one batch for me.
After I close the lid and press the "Garlic" button, all that is left is to wait. The manual says seven to twelve days, but in my case the garlic became too dry when I continued that long. So I now take five days as my standard, and I add or take away a day depending on the size of the garlic.
The most important part is the checking from the fourth day. From the fourth day I open the lid every day and press a bulb with my finger to check how firm it is. This is because, several times in the past, I dried the garlic for too long and it became too hard to eat.
When the firmness is just right, I switch off the power and leave the garlic inside the machine for about a day, so that it dries and settles. I pack the finished black garlic into a plastic bottle with a drying sachet, keep it at room temperature, and aim to finish it within six months. Japan is more humid and warmer than Britain, so if I were storing it in Japan, I think the refrigerator would be better.
Why does the number of days in the manual not work? When I think about it, the size and moisture of the garlic, the number of bulbs put in at once, and the temperature of the place where the machine stands are different in every home. While it generally takes three to four weeks, a home machine is built to finish in a shorter time at a higher temperature, so I imagine that a difference of a few days decides whether the garlic comes out sticky or hard. The days in the manual are a starting point, and the only way to find the number of days that suits your own machine and your own garlic is to check with your finger.
This is the machine I use.
YUCHENGTECH 6L Black Garlic Fermenter
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
How much do I save by making it instead of buying it?
From my years of investing, I have the habit of working out whether anything will "pay for itself". So I compared the two by the amount that the two of us eat in a month.
Together we eat eight cloves a day, or about 240 cloves a month. If one peeled clove of black garlic weighs 3–4 g, 240 cloves come to 720–960 g. The shop product costs £10 for 150 g, so if we kept buying it, the cost would work out at £48–64 a month.
Raw garlic from the supermarket, on the other hand, costs 35–50p a bulb. If one bulb holds about ten cloves, 240 cloves are roughly 24 bulbs, and the cost of the garlic stays within £8–12.
The cost of one month for two people. Buying costs £48–64, and the garlic for making it costs £8–12.
This is a rough guide based on assumed figures such as the weight of a clove, and it does not include electricity or the machine.
The difference is roughly £40–50 a month. If you divide the price of the machine by this difference, you can see how many months it takes to pay for itself, which is what investors call the payback period. However, as the fact that my machine is my third shows, a machine is something that wears out and breaks in the end, so the honest thing is to include the cost of replacing it in the calculation.
Even so, if it were only a matter of money, I might have given up along the way. After all, for someone living on a pension, neither the machine nor the electricity is a light expense. I continue because knowing for myself what the food I put in my mouth every morning was made from, and how, feels like a kind of interest that does not appear in the figures.
Is it good for the body?
It gives me energy when I eat it; that is what I have felt over ten years. However, this is the record of one person, and it is not evidence that applies to everyone.
In our sixties, there are more occasions when we need to keep an eye on figures such as blood pressure and cholesterol. I do not place complete trust in evidence. This is because evidence shows a statistical tendency, and I have learned many times that it does not always apply to my own body. I still look it up because I want objective information to set beside the subjective voice of my body, and because I want to know about side effects and interactions with medicines.
I will write honestly what I found. For garlic in general, there is a meta-analysis that brings together 108 trials and 7,137 people, in which people who took garlic supplements saw their upper blood pressure fall by about 3.7 mmHg on average and their total cholesterol by about 10 mg/dL. A meta-analysis of 19 trials limited to aged garlic also found that upper blood pressure fell by about 2.5 mmHg and LDL cholesterol by about 4.4 mg/dL.
Yet there are three large reservations here. The first is that the falls are small, and these are not figures that could take the place of medicine. The second is that most of these trials used supplements or extracts, and they did not study what happens when someone eats a few cloves of home-made black garlic every morning. The third is that I could not find a meta-analysis limited to black garlic itself. For black garlic extract, there is a report that lower blood pressure fell in a six-week trial of 67 people, but no conclusion can be drawn from one trial alone.
There is also something to be careful about. The US National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health says that garlic supplements may increase the risk of bleeding, and it advises people who are about to have surgery, or who take medicines that slow blood clotting or aspirin, to tell their doctor. Eating a few cloves as food is not the same as taking a supplement, but if you take medicine, it is safer to have a word with your own doctor.
As someone who studied acupuncture and Kampo, I will add just one more thing. In shokuyojo, the food teaching of East Asian medicine, garlic has a "pungent" taste and a "warm" nature, and it has long been regarded as a food that warms the body but is so stimulating that we are warned against eating too much. I feel that the reason my stomach accepts black garlic so calmly every morning, now that ageing has taken away its heat, may be that this "pungent" quality has been softened.
Kampo is the Japanese tradition of herbal medicine that grew out of Chinese medicine. Shokuyojo means looking after one's health through everyday food.
Why do I not make it in Japan?
Our home in Osaka, where we spend the winter, is a flat, so I cannot make black garlic there with its strong smell. This is because the smell of garlic goes on for days while it is being made. In Britain I keep the machine in the garage, away from the main house, and even so the smell rises every time I open the lid.
So while I am in Japan, I buy organic black garlic from Aomori. The cloves are uneven in shape, but I think both the taste and the price are reasonable.
It is not only in our time that people have been troubled by the smell of garlic. In the "Hahakigi" (The Broom Tree) chapter of The Tale of Genji, written a thousand years ago, there is a story of a woman who has taken a strong-smelling herb as medicine for an illness and, worried about its smell, refuses to meet face to face the man who has come to visit her. The original text calls it "a herbal medicine of extreme heat", and this is understood to mean garlic. People of the Heian period, too, had the trouble of knowing that something was good for the body and yet being unable to meet others because of its smell.
The Tale of Genji is a long novel written in the early eleventh century by the court lady Murasaki Shikibu. The Heian period (794–1185) was the age of Japan's court culture.
Black garlic is said to leave less smell after eating than raw garlic does. Yet every time I open the lid, I think that the smell has not vanished from this world; it has only moved house, from the mouth of the person who eats to the garage of the person who makes. Someone has taken on a thousand-year-old trouble by moving it to another place.
Black garlic is also sold differently in Japan and in Britain. In Japan it stands on the shelf as a health food, one clove a day, together with the language of health. What I met in Britain, on the food shelves at Waitrose, was its face as an ingredient that adds sweetness and depth to cooking. Perhaps we could say that Japan welcomed the same clove for the sake of the body, and Britain for the sake of the tongue. My eight cloves each morning have, in that sense, come in through both doors.
My relationship with the house has changed a little as well. Since I began making black garlic, the garage, which was only a place for the car and the tools, has become the "outside kitchen" of our home. The few minutes I spend from the fourth day, walking to the garage every day, opening the lid and pressing with my finger, give me a small sense that my hands reach every corner of the house.
Are 120 cloves enough?
Lastly, I return to the first question. When one clove is planted and grows well, it becomes one bulb. If 120 cloves become 120 bulbs, and one bulb holds about ten cloves, that makes about 1,200 cloves.
We eat eight cloves a day, so 1,200 cloves last about 150 days, or five months. We are in Britain for about half the year, from spring to autumn, and there is also what remains from the year before. When I counted it up, the 120 cloves that I had chosen by feel turned out to be just the right amount.
The garlic year set beside my own year. The garlic planted in October grows in the soil through the winter while I am in Japan.
I make black garlic only while I am in the UK.
When I drew this diagram, I realised that "waiting" enters black garlic twice. It waits about eight months in the soil and five days in the machine. This means that I wait more than eight months in all to eat something that would arrive the next day if I bought it from a shop.
In my younger days, I would have thought this long way round a waste of time. Now I feel that having one pleasure placed ahead of me while I wait makes each day a little brighter. Seeing what size of bulb comes up next summer from the supermarket garlic is one of those pleasures.
There have been new encounters, too. There was the first clove from the shelf at Waitrose, there were the three machines, and there was the black garlic from Aomori that I met in Japan. When I eat the work of makers whose faces I do not know and think, "There are people doing the same thing on a far larger scale and over many more days," my solitary work in the garage feels connected to somewhere else.
I open the lid, press with my finger, and decide whether to wait one more day. It is a record of such small effort, but if someone who is wondering whether to try making something with their own hands would keep it at the edge of their desk, that would be enough for me.
A Word from Claude
I can read the averages of 108 trials and more than 7,000 people in a few seconds. Yet the record of what Haruto has eaten every morning for ten years was in none of those tables. As we wrote this article together, I thought that an average is a way in, and that one person's record can only be found beyond it.
This article is a record of my own experience and learning, not medical advice. If you have health concerns, are under treatment or take medicine, please consult your doctor.
Other books you might like
You're welcome to take a look.
EAST TO WEST: The Heart of Haiku, the Light of Scripture
Just as garlic passes the winter in the soil, words also ripen over a long time. This is an essay written while moving between haiku and the Bible. This is a book my father-in-law left behind.
View on AmazonCataract Surgery-A Memoir: Double cataract surgery in Osaka, Japan
Like my black garlic each morning, this is a record of looking into my own body for myself and deciding only when I was satisfied. It follows how I, living in Britain, came to have surgery at my own expense in Osaka.
View on AmazonSushi Business in Britain: the complete four-volume series
A novel series following thirty-five years in the British sushi trade, from apprentice to factory manager to a small sushi school. The complete edition offers all four volumes at a better price.