🎧 Listen to the Discussion(two hosts talk through their thoughts on this article)
This is an AI-generated audio overview of this article, created with Google NotebookLM. Two hosts discuss the article together, sharing their own thoughts and commentary — it is not a reading of the article text.
Rereading a Doctor's Peak Health in Your 60s with a Former Medical Student's Eye ― Which of His Five "New Rules" I Took Up
The years between average life expectancy and healthy life expectancy. In Japan the gap is about 9 years for men and 12 for women. In the UK (ONS, 2022 to 2024) it is about 18 years for men and 22 for women. The definitions differ, so the two cannot be compared directly, but for me, living in England, this gap became the starting point for reading the book.
I first read Seiichi Hirasawa's Peak Health in Your 60s some years ago on Kindle Unlimited, and only once. This month I rejoined Kindle Unlimited and read it again, this time with the highlighter on. The first time, I finished it thinking "I see", but the second time I found myself writing "Is that true?" or "Where is the evidence?" in my notes twelve times against 97 highlights. This is because I spent five years at a Japanese medical school when I was young and then practised acupuncture and Kampo for many years in Britain, and that history has left me with a habit of reading a doctor's health book without deciding in advance either that "a doctor wrote it, so it must be right" or that "it is a book about supplements, so it must be suspect".
Kampo is the Japanese school of traditional herbal medicine, developed from Chinese medicine over several centuries and practised in Japan alongside Western medicine.
This article is not a summary of the book. It sorts the author's "five new rules of health from your 60s" one by one into "what is well established" and "what is the author's clinical impression", and then records which of them I, at 66, actually took up (zinc, going out to meet people, breakfast as a daily rhythm, drinking less in the evening) and which I set aside (medical testosterone replacement, calcium supplements). These are records of my own case, not a recommendation.
Looking at Japan's "nine-year gap" from England
Near the beginning, the author writes this (my translation).
Between average life expectancy and average healthy life expectancy there is a gap of about 9 years for men and about 12 years for women. In other words, the period in which people need support or care and face limits on daily life is, on average, 9 to 12 years.
When I first read it, I simply felt that nine years was a long time. But when I looked up the figures for Britain, where I now live, my feeling changed. In the Office for National Statistics figures for 2022 to 2024, healthy life expectancy is 60.7 years for men and 60.9 for women, the lowest level since records began. The gap to life expectancy is about 18 years for men and 22 for women, which is nearly double the Japanese figure.
The comparison needs a note, however. Japan's healthy life expectancy is "the period without limits on daily life", while the British one is "the period in which people describe their own health as good or very good"; both are self-reported, but the questions are asked differently. My point is not to rank the two countries by these numbers, but to notice where I stand: I am reading a book that laments Japan's nine years in a country where the gap is eighteen. As the figures show, in Britain the number of people with health worries starts to grow, on average, from around the age of 60. So when someone in their 60s in Britain says "while I can still get about", the words carry the meaning "it may only be a few more years". When I hear the same words in Japan, I sense more room in them, something like "before my mid-70s". Since I began this year to divide my retired life between Britain and Japan, the first thing I noticed was this difference in the length of time hidden behind the same words.
The author offers five new rules as tools for narrowing this gap.
- Top up your hormones to prevent ageing of body and mind and live in good health. 2. Top up your minerals to strengthen immunity and keep infections and cancer at bay. 3. Learn the right way to take supplements and put your body in order. 4. Move to a breakfast-centred diet and gain health and long life. 5. Improve nocturia and raise the quality of sleep and of life.
From here, I will go through the five in order.
New rule 1, hormones ― does the "longevity hormone" really make us live longer?
The author is a urologist, and at the centre of the book is testosterone.
Testosterone "develops and strengthens bone" and "builds and increases muscle from protein", giving us a body that resists fractures and tires less easily. Testosterone also keeps the blood vessels supple.
The medical student I once was would have memorised that sentence as it stood and taken it into the exam. The person I am now notices instead that evidence of different strengths is mixed together in a single sentence.
The statements about bone and muscle are on the stronger side. A series of American clinical trials (the T-Trials, 2016 to 2017) confirmed that testosterone replacement raised bone density in older men and improved anaemia. "Keeps the blood vessels supple", on the other hand, is supported in basic research as a mechanism working through nitric oxide, but a large trial published in 2023 (TRAVERSE) found that replacement neither reduced nor increased diseases of the heart and brain vessels, and that atrial fibrillation and pulmonary embolism rose slightly. The "conversion to brown fat" that the author describes is, as far as I could find, still mainly at the stage of animal experiments.
Then there is the biggest headline of all, the name "longevity hormone". There are indeed observational studies showing that people with lower testosterone have higher mortality (the EPIC-Norfolk study in Britain, the Rancho Bernardo study in the United States and others). But this is an association, not a cause. Do people die earlier because their testosterone is low, or is their testosterone low because their bodies are already weakening? An observational study cannot tell the two apart. As far as I know, no trial has shown that replacement extends life.
Written like this, it may read as criticism of the author, but it is not. In his clinic he must have seen many patients regain their energy on replacement therapy, and this book is that experience gathered into one volume. What I want to say is that grading the evidence as you read is not a way of belittling a book; it is a tool for deciding for yourself what to put into your own body.
I myself am not on testosterone replacement. But under the influence of this book, I recently ordered from an overseas online shop a supplement that claims to "support" testosterone. It has only just arrived, so I can say nothing yet. It is a different thing from medical replacement therapy, and I know the evidence is weak, but the honest truth is that I want to see for myself.
The idea that meeting people raises the hormone
The passage where I stopped longest was this one.
By keeping the sense that you are living as a member of society, testosterone is secreted.
I could find no direct evidence, in the range I searched, that meeting people raises testosterone. The same goes for the passage that says a haircut or wearing clothes you like raises the level. Yet here I remembered scurvy in the age of sail. The Royal Navy was giving lime juice to its sailors and preventing scurvy a full 150 years before the substance we call vitamin C was discovered. The explanation came later, and the action had been right first.
That social isolation raises the risk of death is strongly supported by a large meta-analysis of 2015 (Holt-Lunstad). Whether or not testosterone is the reason, the action itself, going out to places where you meet people, is certainly right. For me that place is the sushi school my wife and I run. After two hours of teaching a first-time student how to hold a knife and listening to the story of that person's life, I ought to be tired, and yet I clearly feel strength rising in my body. Whether the reason is a hormone or something else, I do not know. But that feeling moves me more than any paper.
New rule 2, minerals ― does zinc really help "300 enzymes"?
Zinc promotes metabolism and supports the work of more than 300 kinds of enzyme.
Beside this line I wrote "Really?". When I checked, it was true. That zinc is involved in the work of more than 300 enzymes has been a standard textbook statement since the 1990s, and in recent years it has been said to be involved with more than 2,000 proteins. On immunity, there is a clinical trial (Prasad, 2007) in which older people given zinc for a year had fewer infections. On antioxidant action, too, the claim holds up, because zinc is itself a component of one of the body's antioxidant enzymes (SOD).
On the other hand, the passage saying that frail older people are short of zinc is at the stage of "an association has been reported" in observational studies, and cause has not been established. Here I felt the author's wording was one step stronger than the evidence.
Among the things I learnt at medical school, the one that still serves me is the habit of always checking the amount. In Japan's Dietary Reference Intakes (2020 edition), the recommended zinc intake for people aged 65 to 74 is 11 mg for men and 8 mg for women, with a tolerable upper limit of 40 mg for men and 35 mg for women. The British reference nutrient intake is 9.5 mg for men and 7 mg for women. The book says zinc supports immunity, but it does not say "so the more the better". That it is a nutrient with an upper limit is something you have to check for yourself.
After rereading the book I began taking a zinc supplement (20 mg a day, with selenium and chromium). It is early days, so I cannot say whether it has done anything. As a feeling, though, I seem to have a little more energy in the mornings. Whether that is the zinc or simply the fact of having started, I honestly cannot tell. Even so, I am writing it down as a record.
Zinc reminds me of the cucumbers in my greenhouse. When there is not enough zinc in the soil, the leaves of a cucumber turn yellow and the fruit will not develop. What is not in the soil cannot be in the fruit. People are the same: what is not in the food does not get into the body, and the greenhouse teaches me that lesson every year.
If food seems to have lost its taste or no longer seems delicious, first suspect a lack of zinc.
This is something I valued in my own acupuncture practice too. It is in line with Japan's clinical guidance on zinc deficiency (2018), and I think the author is right.
New rule 3, supplements ― the author's seven items, re-sorted by strength of evidence
For my own health I take mainly the following supplements every day: zinc, calcium, magnesium, vitamin D, lactic acid bacteria, astaxanthin and resveratrol.
The author divides these seven into two groups, "making up what food does not supply" and "preventing oxidation". I tried re-sorting the same seven by strength of evidence.
The strongest evidence is for zinc, magnesium and vitamin D. That Japanese magnesium intake falls short of the recommended amount is confirmed every year by the National Health and Nutrition Survey. Vitamin D, however, makes sense for people who are short of it, while a large trial (VITAL, 2019) found that people who were not short of it gained no reduction in cancer or heart disease from taking it. Calcium from food is no problem, but there is a warning (Bolland, 2010) that calcium taken alone as a supplement may raise the risk to heart and blood vessels, so I do not take it as a supplement.
The evidence is weak for astaxanthin and resveratrol. The book says astaxanthin has "6,000 times the antioxidant power of vitamin C", but that figure was measured in a test tube, and the trials showing what happens when people take it are small. Resveratrol was much talked about for a while because animal experiments suggested it activates a longevity gene, but in people it has not produced the hoped-for results (Semba, 2014).
Here I have to be honest. After rereading the book, I ordered astaxanthin and resveratrol from an overseas online shop, knowing the evidence was weak. The head trained at medical school says "weak evidence", and the 66-year-old body says "I want to try". Both voices live in me, and I have decided not to silence either. But I have set conditions: if I feel nothing after three months, I stop, and I record the result.
Of all the author's advice, the sentence I agree with most is this one.
A supplement that works for someone else will not necessarily work for you.
In acupuncture and Kampo alike, the same remedy given to people with the same symptoms works for some and not for others. In East Asian medicine we say their sho, their pattern, is different. Supplements are the same, and the author's order of things, first find out what you are short of, is the same as the way of thinking in East Asian medicine.
Sho is the Kampo term for the individual pattern of a patient's condition, on which the choice of treatment is based rather than on the disease name alone.
The book also gives figures such as "90 per cent of lifestyle diseases are caused by free radicals" and "antioxidant capacity falls to 5 to 30 per cent from the 60s onward", but I could not find their sources, so I do not quote them here.
New rule 4, breakfast ― does miso soup survive an English morning?
Eating breakfast resets the drift in the body clock, steadies the daily rhythm and improves the quality of sleep.
The body clock, morning light and melatonin are a well-founded field. There is also an observational study (Rong, 2019) showing that people who skip breakfast die at a higher rate from heart and vascular disease. On the point that "eating breakfast makes you slimmer", however, a meta-analysis in 2019 (Sievert) came out negative. So I take breakfast not "to lose weight" but "to set the rhythm of the day".
The author recommends soy foods at breakfast: miso soup, tofu, natto. Does that survive an English morning? My answer is that I have settled the matter. While I am in England, breakfast is English; while I am in Japan, it is Japanese. I do not go hunting for natto in England. This is because what my two-country life has taught me is that eating properly in the morning whatever the land you are in lasts longer than trying to keep the same habit everywhere. On an English morning that means eggs, wholemeal bread and tea. On the subject of zinc, the author himself lists eggs as an easy food source of it.
Natto is fermented soybeans, a common Japanese breakfast food with a strong smell and sticky texture.
New rule 5, nocturia ― what I tried, and what changed
Medically, it has not been proven that drinking a lot of water before bed prevents strokes or heart attacks in the night or early morning.
On this, I think the author is right. Japan's clinical guideline on nocturia (2nd edition, 2020) also puts the behavioural approach, limiting fluids from the evening, ahead of medicines. The point that going to the toilet in the night raises the risk of falls and fainting is also correct.
Since first reading the book, I have limited fluids after the evening and dimmed the lights before bed. So did the number of times I get up in the night change? Honestly, no. As before, I get up two or three times. One reason, I think, is that my nocturia does not come from drinking too much but from the mechanism of a body in its 60s itself, in which the bladder holds less and more urine is made at night. The book's behavioural approach should work for people who drink too much, but I was never one of them.
Even so, the book gave me something: the ability to write "it did not change". The old me, on deciding that something "did not work", would have thrown the whole book aside. Now I can accept that one of five simply did not suit me. On nocturia, I have written another article in which I read a urologist's book closely and map out its causes.
What I took up, and what I set aside
Top row: the author's five new rules. Middle: sorted into strong, medium and weak evidence. Bottom: what I took up (zinc, meeting people, breakfast for rhythm) and what I set aside (hormone replacement, calcium supplements).
In summary, it comes to this.
Taken up: zinc (20 mg a day); going out to meet people (the sushi school); eating breakfast for the rhythm; limiting fluids after the evening (no benefit, but no harm, so I continue).
Set aside: medical testosterone replacement; calcium supplements.
On trial, with conditions: astaxanthin and resveratrol (to be judged after three months).
And continued from before: magnesium, vitamin D and omega-3. I wrote about omega-3 in another article.
One note on Kampo. The book says that Kampo medicines "balance the whole body and promote the production and release of testosterone", but it does not name a specific formula. Let me fill that in here. Japan's clinical guidance on LOH syndrome (late-onset hypogonadism) mentions the formula Hochuekkito, and small trials have reported improvement in symptoms and free testosterone. From the East Asian side, the "no drive" and "heavy lower back" of one's 60s are read as jinkyo, a weakening of the kidney system, and my usual measure in practice was a formula such as Hachimijiogan to support the strength of the kidney. The Western word "hormone" and the Eastern word "jinkyo" are, I think, two windows on the same change in the same body.
Hochuekkito and Hachimijiogan are classical Kampo formulas, the first used for fatigue and weak digestion, the second for the frailty of later life. Jinkyo, "kidney deficiency", is the Kampo reading of age-related decline in vitality; the "kidney" here means a system of vital energy, not only the organ.
Left, my day before reading; right, after. Morning went from "eat something" to "eat for the rhythm". After the evening, fewer fluids; at night, lights down and screens closed. The count of night-time trips did not change, but the shape of the day did.
Body and mind, money, and meeting people ― what this reading left in my retirement
How does reading help the "settling of body and mind" in my retired life? In the case of this book, what remained was the sense of having decided for myself what to put into my body. Not taking something because a friend recommended it or because I saw it on television, but reading the evidence, checking the amount and setting a deadline for the trial. That procedure itself steadies the mind.
Money deserves a word too. Supplements are no small expense for a pensioner. Zinc, magnesium, vitamin D, omega-3, and now astaxanthin and resveratrol; several thousand yen, or a few tens of pounds, go out every month. The reason I continue even so is that I have made a promise to myself to review everything at three months. What I feel is doing nothing, I stop. Because of that promise, the expense becomes an investment; without it, it would be nothing more than an offering.
And meeting people. Rereading this book gave me, for the first time, a reason for the act of going out to places where people gather. The students who come to the sushi school range in age from their 20s to their 60s, and they come not only from Britain but from many countries. With those of my own generation I laugh, knives in hand, over jar lids that will not open and stairs that leave us breathless, and from the younger ones I hear about the dinner tables of countries I do not know. Those two hours are the best "top-up" I know. This article is an extension of that time. Even when words travel only one way, they can become someone's support; I write in that belief.
About the author, Seiichi Hirasawa
The author, Seiichi Hirasawa, is a urologist. In the book he describes himself like this.
As a urologist, and as president of the Shinjuku Medical Association, I have faced the bodies and minds of the patients who come to my clinic and of the people of the district.
He goes on to say that at the time of writing he was 67 and that "life really begins from the 60s". In other words, this is not a book by a researcher in geriatrics, but by a clinician of my own generation who has seen patients every day in a city-centre clinic and tested his ideas on his own body.
That explains both the strength and the weakness of the book. The strength is what only a urologist can see. Testosterone replacement, the link between zinc and taste, the behavioural treatment of nocturia; all of these come up almost daily in a urology clinic, and the author's conviction grows from there. His remark that it is a pity replacement therapy is not yet widespread in Japan is, I think, the remark of someone who has watched patients recover their energy many times.
The weakness comes from the same source. Clinical impression reaches only as far as the number of patients one doctor can see. I took the passages about meeting people or caring for one's appearance raising testosterone as the author's attempt to explain, with the single word "hormone", changes he had watched in his patients. The explanation may be a hypothesis, but the observation is real.
The book came out in 2021, when the word "frailty" was spreading in Japan and "healthy life expectancy" had become a term of public policy. The author's careful definition of frailty reflects the air of that time. At the same moment in Britain, the healthy life expectancy of older people had begun to fall during the pandemic. The same phrase, "healthy life expectancy", was being spoken in Japan and in Britain with entirely different urgency, I now think, looking back.
Related books
The book I reread has no English edition. For readers in English, a book that covers the same ground, healthy life expectancy, testosterone and exercise, is Outlive by Peter Attia (2023).
Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity (Peter Attia MD), Kindle edition
Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity (Peter Attia MD), hardcover
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
Other books you might like
You're welcome to take a look.
Cataract Surgery-A Memoir: Double cataract surgery in Osaka, Japan
A record of surgery in which I checked the doctor's explanations against my own eyes and body; written in the same spirit as this article: neither swallowing nor dismissing, but checking.
View on AmazonThis article is a record of my own experience and reading, not medical advice. If you have an existing condition or are under treatment, please consult your doctor before starting any supplement.