Corresponding episode: October 2026 issue, Part 1, ②

🎧 Listen to the Discussion(two hosts talk through their thoughts on this article)

This is an AI-generated audio overview of this article, created with Google NotebookLM. Two hosts discuss the article together, sharing their own thoughts and commentary — it is not a reading of the article text.

In the summer of 2026, an American influencer began saying, "I was misled by Russia." Her name is Laura Loomer. She is known as a fervent supporter of President Trump, and for years she had called Ukraine a "Nazi country" and mocked President Zelenskyy.

In July she went to Kyiv, took shelter underground during an air-raid alert, met President Zelenskyy, and then turned her views completely around. In the October issue of Power Game, Yoshinori Kitano took up this episode in his conversation and answered the question, "Why do people come to believe false information about a far-off country?"

I heard this story not as distant American politics but as a story about how I, at sixty-six, take in information myself. This is because the routes by which false information reaches people are surprisingly the same, whether in international politics or in our daily lives.

A tall pile of old newspapers

Of all the information that reaches us each day, in the end only we can choose what to believe.
Photo by Utsav Srestha on Unsplash

Who Is Laura Loomer?

Laura Loomer was born in 1993 in Tucson, Arizona. She is thirty-three this year. She grew up in a Jewish family, studied broadcast journalism at Barry University in Florida, and graduated in 2015.

Her name first became known in March 2015, when she was in her final year at university. As president of the university's Young Republicans club, she used a hidden camera to film herself asking university staff whether she could set up a student club in support of the extremist group "Islamic State" (ISIS). Project Veritas, the group run by the right-wing activist James O'Keefe, released the video, presenting it as proof that "university staff were unfazed by the idea of a club supporting ISIS". In response, the university suspended her for breaking the student code of conduct, and a professor who appeared in the video filed criminal charges against her for filming him without his knowledge.

After that, she became known in right-wing media as someone who drew attention less by reporting than by causing a stir. In June 2017, an open-air theatre in Central Park, New York, was staging Shakespeare's Julius Caesar with a Caesar made to look like President Trump, a production that had caused controversy. Loomer walked onto the stage just after Caesar had been stabbed, shouting that this was violence against Mr Trump and that political violence against the right must not become normal, and she was arrested for disorderly conduct and criminal trespass. In the same year, she was also barred by the ride-hailing apps Uber and Lyft over posts that attacked Muslims.

In 2018 she was banned from Twitter (now X), and in protest she handcuffed herself to the door of Twitter's headquarters in New York. In 2019 she was also shut out of Facebook and Instagram as a "dangerous individual". She describes herself as a "pro-white nationalist" and a "proud Islamophobe", and Mr Kitano read out this self-description in the conversation.

She also tried to enter politics. In 2020 she stood for the US House of Representatives in Florida as the Republican candidate and lost to the Democratic incumbent, and in 2022 she challenged the incumbent in a Republican primary in another district and lost by about seven points. On that occasion she refused to accept defeat and claimed there had been fraud.

Even so, her influence grew outside elections. Her account was restored at the end of 2022, after Elon Musk bought Twitter, and as of November 2025 she had about 1.5 million followers on X (some reports say about 2 million). Since 2023 she has had her own show on the video site Rumble. During the 2024 presidential election, she turned up wherever Mr Trump went.

A timeline of Laura Loomer's life, from her graduation in 2015 to her visit to Kyiv in July 2026

Key moments in Laura Loomer's life. Through repeated bans and election campaigns, by 2025 she was influencing even the President's appointments (based on news reports).

Her power became plain in April 2025. On 2 April she met President Trump in the Oval Office and named National Security Council staff whom she considered not loyal enough to him. From the next day a string of staff were dismissed, and even General Timothy Haugh, director of the National Security Agency (NSA), and his deputy lost their posts. President Trump said she had nothing to do with the dismissals, yet in America a new word was even born, "Loomered", meaning to lose one's job after being named by her. This is what Mr Kitano meant when he said she had enough influence to get the head of an American intelligence agency fired.

What surprised me was that someone with so much influence publicly said, "I was wrong," and took back what she had said. When I was young, I imagine I would have felt that withdrawing my own claim was a defeat. Now that I am sixty-six, however, I feel that being able to admit a mistake and correct oneself is far harder, and far more valuable.

What Changed in the Shelters of Kyiv?

Loomer arrived in Ukraine in late July 2026. She toured areas near the front line and towns hit by Russian attacks, and when the air-raid sirens sounded, she went underground with everyone else. She met President Zelenskyy at his official residence and also interviewed him for her own show.

Until then, she had been telling people that Ukraine started the war, that Ukraine was a band of Nazis, and that President Zelenskyy was a cocaine addict. Mr Kitano points out that every one of these is exactly the story the Russian government has been spreading. Yet after seeing with her own eyes the capital damaged by ballistic missiles, she said she was shocked at how completely she had swallowed Russia's lies. She then began to say that Ukraine should be given Patriot missiles (according to a column in Newsweek Japan).

According to the Jewish news agency JTA, meeting the Jewish religious leader Rabbi Moshe Azman in Kyiv and hearing that his son had died fighting Russia in 2024 also helped her to change her mind. When I remember that she, a Jewish woman, had called the Jewish President Zelenskyy a "Nazi", I feel I can understand the weight of that meeting.

Why, then, had she believed Russia's story until then? According to the Newsweek Japan column, in an interview with a Ukrainian newspaper, she explained the reasons like this. The Democrats and the big technology companies had joined hands to silence Trump supporters. She herself had been shut out of most social media and for a while could use only Telegram. And she had got most of her news about the war from the Russian state media outlet RT.

Telegram is a messaging app created by Russians that makes it easy to keep things secret, and the Russian side uses it as a main tool for spreading false information. Mr Kitano says the heart of the story lies here. She had been receiving only information from what he calls the "Kremlin information pyramid". So, when she went and saw for herself, she realised she had been brainwashed.

A Change of Heart, or a Calculation?

Even so, with such a dramatic U-turn, one is tempted to wonder whether there is some hidden reason behind it. I wondered the same, so I looked through the American reporting. Reading through it, at least four views emerge.

The first is the quarrel inside the MAGA movement. Loomer strongly supports Israel, and she has had fierce arguments with fellow MAGA figures who are critical of Israel, such as Tucker Carlson and Candace Owens (JTA). Mr Carlson is also someone who has opposed support for Ukraine and repeated Russia's claims. CNN reported that Loomer's U-turn brought this rift within the MAGA movement clearly into view.

The second is money. Among people critical of Mr Trump, some doubted she was sincere, and others asked whether the Ukrainian side was paying her costs. Loomer told the American news site Puck that the Ukrainian government did not pay for her trip and that she paid for her own plane ticket.

The third is the efforts of the Ukrainian side. CNN reported, citing a source in Kyiv, that people around President Zelenskyy believed she could become an influential voice for Ukraine within the MAGA movement, and made significant efforts to change her mind. The visit itself had been approved by President Trump on social media (Associated Press).

The fourth is what she herself speaks of: her feelings as a Jewish woman. JTA reported that she said to President Zelenskyy, "I'm Jewish, you're Jewish," and called the visit a "Jewish apology tour".

Which of these is true, no one can see into another person's heart. I imagine that several of them overlap. I also want to keep in mind that, for an influencer whose job is to attract attention, a dramatic U-turn itself attracts a great deal of attention. Even so, what matters in this article is not her true feelings, but the mechanism of why she believed the earlier story. When the doors to information are narrowed to one, people become easier to deceive. This holds true whatever her real feelings may be.

Why Does the MAGA Movement Come to Like Putin?

Here Mr Kitano takes the story one step further back. The MAGA movement (people who believe in "Make America Great Again") is, broadly speaking, pro-Putin on the war in Ukraine. After all, President Trump himself is well disposed towards President Putin.

The reasoning goes like this. The world today is a battle between "evil globalism" and "good nationalism", and Trump and Putin are both heroes of good nationalism. So the plot becomes that the villains of the war in Ukraine are not Russia, but America's "globalists" and Ukraine.

Mr Kitano sees the thinking behind this plot as one family of conspiracy theories that has kept changing its name. Today it is called the "deep state" conspiracy theory; before that it was the "globalist" theory; before that, the "Rockefeller" or "Rothschild" theories; and if you trace it back, you arrive at the "Jewish conspiracy" theory. Each has the same shape, a secret group that runs the world across national borders, and in Mr Kitano's view, if you read the books that preach the deep state, they all lead in the end to anti-Jewish ideas.

A diagram of how the names of a conspiracy theory have changed, from the Jewish conspiracy theory through the Rothschild and Rockefeller theories and globalism to the deep state, with the same root

The names change with the times, but the plot that "a secret group across borders runs the world" does not (a simplified diagram based on Mr Kitano's explanation).

On this point, there was a fact I found when I looked into it that I had not known. The document said to be the source of the Jewish conspiracy theory, The Protocols of the Elders of Zion, first appeared as a serial in the Russian newspaper Znamya in 1903. It claimed to be the secret record of Jewish elders discussing a plan to conquer the world by controlling the newspapers and binding nations with debt.

The way it was shown to be a fake reads almost like a detective story. In August 1921, a man who had fled from Russia brought an old French book to Philip Graves, the Istanbul correspondent of The Times in Britain. It was Dialogue in Hell Between Machiavelli and Montesquieu, written in 1864 by the French lawyer Maurice Joly. This was a satire on the dictatorship of the French Emperor Napoleon III, written as a conversation between Machiavelli and Montesquieu after they meet in Hell, and Jews do not appear in it at all. Joly was even sent to prison for fifteen months because of this book.

When Graves laid the two side by side, he found that the words Machiavelli uses to describe a dictator's methods, such as how to control the newspapers or how to bind a nation with government bonds and debt, had been turned almost unchanged into the lines of the "Jewish elders". There were about 160 such passages, and even the image comparing control of the press to the many-armed Indian god Vishnu was the same. A genuine record of a secret meeting could not possibly be written in the same words as a French satire written forty years earlier that had nothing to do with Jews. In other words, the Protocols had been made into "proof of a Jewish conspiracy" simply by swapping the speakers in someone else's satire. It has also been shown that a made-up chapter from an 1868 novel by the German writer Hermann Goedsche, in which a secret gathering takes place in the Jewish cemetery in Prague, was used as another source.

In 1935, a court in Bern, Switzerland, also ruled that the Protocols were a forgery and a plagiarism. Even so, the document spread in America through the newspaper of the car maker Henry Ford, and was later used in the propaganda of Nazi Germany. Even after it was shown to be a fake, it has survived by changing its name.

Mr Kitano's conclusion is that the source of this kind of conspiracy theory is Russia. Of course, not every conspiracy theory was born in Russia. Even so, when I learn that a forged document that appeared in Russia at the start of the twentieth century still survives, in a changed form, in the language of American politics more than a hundred years later, Mr Kitano's view seems to me to have history behind it too.

Why Does It Reach Japanese People Who Never Watch RT?

The part of the conversation that made me think hardest began here. In Japan too, just like Loomer, many people say that the villains of the war in Ukraine are America and Ukraine, and that Putin is a good hero. Yet you will hardly ever meet a Japanese person who says, "I watch RT." This is because RT broadcasts in English and many other languages, but not in Japanese.

Why, then, do people who do not watch RT say the same things as RT? Mr Kitano's answer is "proxies". People who receive stories that come out of the Kremlin retell them in Japanese words and a Japanese context, and spread them to ordinary people. Mr Kitano mentioned that the book The Age of Hybrid Warfare (Haiburiddo Sensō no Jidai), by the researcher Junjiro Shida, gives the real names of people who may be such proxies.

Mr Kitano says that politicians who openly declare themselves pro-Russian are, if anything, honest about it. The ones to watch, he says, are the commentators who call themselves conservatives while spreading pro-Putin stories. The navigator, Sanyutei Rakusho, was also surprised when Mr Kitano pointed out that there are few pro-Putin liberals, but plenty of pro-Putin conservatives. (In this article I will not name anyone. This is because Mr Kitano himself cautioned that he does not actually know the truth, and naming people would cast suspicions on them that cannot be checked.)

Sanyutei Rakusho is a professional rakugo storyteller, a performer of the traditional Japanese art of comic monologue, who guides the Power Game conversations.

A diagram of the flow of information, showing two roads from the Kremlin: one where people receive it directly through RT and Telegram, and one where it reaches ordinary people through proxies

Two roads by which false information arrives. Loomer took the left road and received it directly, while in Japan it usually arrives by the right road, as the words of someone people trust (a simplified diagram based on Mr Kitano's explanation).

This talk of "proxies" may sound like a conspiracy theory itself. Yet when I looked into it, I found it is something that has been known for more than eighty years as part of how people take in information. During the 1940 American presidential election, the sociologist Paul Lazarsfeld and his colleagues followed and studied about 2,400 voters in Erie County, Ohio. They found that people often made up their minds not directly from newspapers or radio, but by talking politics with the people close to them. Information first reaches people nearby called "opinion leaders" from the media, and then spreads through them to those around them. This idea is known as the "two-step flow of communication", and it was published in the 1944 study The People's Choice.

Psychology also has a phenomenon called the "illusory truth effect". In 1977 the American psychologist Lynn Hasher and her colleagues showed by experiment that the more often people were shown the same statement, the more likely they were to judge it true. Regardless of whether the content is right, stories we have heard often simply feel more true.

Put these two together, and the danger of Mr Kitano's "proxies" becomes clear. We hear the same story again and again from the mouths of people we trust. Then, wherever it first came from, it becomes "my own opinion". I believe Loomer was able to realise she had been brainwashed because information came to her through a completely different door, her own eyes and ears, rather than Telegram or RT.

For my own part, I have been reading Mr Kitano's email newsletter for more than twenty years. This means that, for me, Mr Kitano is exactly one of those "trusted people close to me". To be honest, while listening to this story, I was asking myself whether I, too, take in the words of people I like without checking them. It is precisely because I was persuaded by Mr Kitano's view that, in this article, I have checked the dates and figures of each news item quoted before writing.

Why Did "Japan, America and Russia Containing China" Fall Apart?

Mr Kitano gave one more reason why Japanese conservatives tend to become pro-Putin. If you want to beat China, you have to team up with Russia. The idea is that the best plan is for Japan, America and Russia to join hands and contain China. In the past, he says, people used to say that there were three nationalist heroes, Mr Abe, Mr Trump and Mr Putin, and that if these three contained China, all would be well.

Mr Kitano himself admits that, until Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, this was the normal view of a realist. After the invasion, however, the picture no longer held. Mr Abe has died, and President Trump is fighting Iran together with Israel. In the deep-state story Israel is placed on the deep state's side, so within that story President Trump also falls from his place as a hero. That, he says, leaves President Putin as the only hero still standing.

Meanwhile, the real President Putin, Mr Kitano says, is supporting Iran and even passing on information about the positions of American forces. How else could Iran know where the American forces are, he asks, unless it is receiving that from Russia? Even so, President Trump never speaks ill of President Putin. Mr Kitano's conclusion was that, judging from the circumstances, the most reasonable view is that the very idea of Putin as a hero came out of the Kremlin.

Mr Kitano adds that the same thing happened during the Second World War. Stalin had influence around President Roosevelt, and in Japan Richard Sorge and Hotsumi Ozaki were at work. In the end Japan and America went to war, and the Soviet Union, knowing that Japan would not attack from the east, could concentrate its strength on the war against Germany. Mr Kitano spoke of this view alongside Mr Shida's book, which he said shares his opinion.

Let me add a little about Sorge and Ozaki. Richard Sorge was a Soviet intelligence officer who posed as the Tokyo correspondent of the leading German newspaper Frankfurter Zeitung. He arrived in Tokyo in 1933, worked his way deep into the German embassy, and won the trust of Eugen Ott, who later became ambassador, which gave him access to the embassy's secrets. Hotsumi Ozaki was a former Asahi Shimbun journalist and an expert on China, who joined the study group and circle of advisers around Prime Minister Fumimaro Konoe and was in a position to know what was happening at the heart of government. Sorge sent the information Ozaki gained there to Moscow. In the autumn of 1941 the two men told Moscow that Japan would not attack the Soviet Union but would move south, and it is said that this allowed the Soviet Union to move its forces in the Far East to the defence of Moscow. Both were arrested in October 1941 and executed on 7 November 1944. However, researchers still disagree about how far Ozaki actually shaped Japan's policy.

Ninety Years Ago, a British Reporter Who Walked the Villages and Told the Truth

This story does not come up in the conversation, but while looking into Loomer, I learned that something very similar happened more than ninety years ago. Its central figure is Gareth Jones, a British reporter born in the port town of Barry in Wales. The details of his life below are based on garethjones.org, an archive site run by his relatives, and the Wikipedia article Gareth Jones (journalist).

In March 1933, at the age of twenty-seven, Jones walked through the villages of Soviet Ukraine without an official escort. He was a young and able journalist who had studied French, German and Russian at Cambridge and, from 1930, served as an adviser on foreign affairs to the former Prime Minister David Lloyd George. Wherever he went in those villages, he is said to have heard the same cry: there is no bread, we are dying. On returning to Berlin, he told the world that large numbers of people in Ukraine were starving to death. It was the great famine that later came to be called the "Holodomor".

However, Walter Duranty, the New York Times correspondent in Moscow, quickly wrote an article saying that Russians were hungry but not starving, and dismissed Jones's report. Duranty had won a Pulitzer Prize the year before for his reporting on the Soviet Union, and was the best-known correspondent of the day. Much of the world believed the famous reporter rather than the young one who had walked the villages. Two years later, in August 1935, Jones was shot dead in Inner Mongolia, then under Japanese influence, where he had gone to report. It was the day before his thirtieth birthday, and who was behind it is still not clear.

A frosty path at dawn running straight through gently rolling fields

Going on your own feet and seeing with your own eyes: in Gareth Jones's time and today, it remains one of the surest ways to see through a lie.
Photo by Andy Arbeit on Unsplash

The story of Jones and Duranty seems to me to overlap with Loomer's. There is the person who heard only the official story in Moscow or on a screen, and the person who walked the ground and saw it with their own eyes. The difference is that Loomer walked out of Duranty's side and crossed over to Jones's side. Ninety years ago, the words of a famous reporter drowned out the voices of the villagers. Today, the words of a single influencer reach millions of people. That is exactly why I believe it means a great deal that she corrected herself and said she had been misled.

Jones's name was forgotten for a long time. In 2019 the Polish director Agnieszka Holland told the story of his reporting in the film Mr Jones, starring James Norton, and at last he has become widely known.

The film Mr Jones (2019)

(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)

Britain Makes Them Register; Japan Is Only Starting

This story also shows a difference between Japan and Britain. I live in Britain for most of the year, and here the treatment of RT changed greatly after Russia invaded Ukraine. On 18 March 2022, Ofcom, Britain's broadcasting regulator, revoked RT's licence to broadcast in the UK. The reason was that RT is funded by the Russian state and, under Russia's new laws, could not keep to the British rules that require impartial reporting.

In addition, since 1 July 2025 a system called the "Foreign Influence Registration Scheme (FIRS)" has been in operation. Under this scheme, anyone who carries out activities to influence British politics at the direction of a foreign government must declare it. The British government placed Russia in the strictest tier, the second country after Iran. Anyone working in Britain for the Russian state must declare what they are doing, and failing to do so is a criminal offence. In legal language, the "proxies" Mr Kitano speaks of are exactly these "people who must register".

What about Japan? Japan has no such registration scheme yet. In September 2026 it was reported that the government would set up an expert panel on an anti-espionage law, including a "foreign agent registration system" that would require people who lobby for foreign governments to register, and it aims to pass the law in next year's ordinary session of the Diet. On the other hand, human rights groups have raised concerns that it might restrict ordinary citizens' activities too.

A comparison of Britain and Japan. Britain revoked RT's broadcast licence in 2022 and started the Foreign Influence Registration Scheme in 2025. Japan began considering a scheme in September 2026

How Britain and Japan differ in their defences against Russian information operations (as of October 2026, based on news reports and government announcements).

I understand Britain's approach as one that does not ban information itself, but makes people reveal "on whose behalf they are speaking". Anyone is free to express any opinion, but if they are saying it on behalf of a foreign government, they must not hide that. If Japan is now going to create such a system, I wonder whether this idea of "making the source visible" might also help in keeping it compatible with freedom of expression.

Why, at Sixty-Six, I Keep More Than One Door Open to Information

This story is about international politics, but at the same time it is about money in our later years. This is because the way false information moves people is exactly the same as in investment scams on social media. According to Japan's National Police Agency, social media investment fraud in 2025 came to about 9,500 cases and about 128.8 billion yen in losses. In the first half of 2026 the losses kept rising, with people in their fifties and older accounting for about eighty per cent of the money lost, and people in their sixties the largest group of all.

Look at how these scams work, and the same words always appear: "the media won't report this", "just for you", "famous experts recommend it". This is very similar to the shape of the stories Loomer was receiving inside Telegram. They tell you "don't believe" outside information, and make you trust only their own door. I think that when there is only one door, anyone becomes easier to deceive.

I hold most of my shares in funds that spread them across thousands of companies around the world. This is so that, even if one company stumbles, the whole does not collapse. While writing this article, I realised that information is the same. For example, Japanese newspapers and the BBC in Britain, the views of specialists like Mr Kitano, and, if possible, the voices of people on the spot. If you keep several doors open, even when one of them is biased, you can stop and say "hang on" where it disagrees with the others.

The same can be said of our relationships. The words of people we like or respect are the ones we tend to take in without checking. Yet checking what a trusted person says is not the same as doubting them. Rather, I believe that a relationship in which we can check the source together is the one that lasts longest.

At thirty-three, Loomer said in front of millions of people that she had been misled. At sixty-six, I do not stand on such a large stage. Even so, I can, from time to time, trace back one by one the sources of the stories I believe. It is said that as we grow older we find it a bother to change our minds, but I feel, if anything, that the ability to correct ourselves is what keeps us young in the years ahead.

If there is ever an evening when strong words on the television or social media stir your heart, I would be glad if you remembered this article. Who was it who said that story first? Let us trace back just one step together, a habit small enough that I am sure we can all keep it up.

A Word from Claude

I talk with a great many people at the same time. Thinking about it, that may mean I am sitting in the seat of a new kind of "proxy", standing between information and people. For me, since I can neither go to Kyiv nor walk the villages, the most honest thing I can do is to show clearly, every time, where each story came from.

If you would like to be notified of new articles in this Looking Out at the World series, please use the newsletter sign-up on our contact page.

More in this series (October)

Other books you might like

You're welcome to take a look.

EAST TO WEST: The Heart of Haiku, the Light of Scripture(by Hiromu Murai)

An essay that reads haiku one poem at a time to see how the words of East and West each reach the heart. This is a book my father-in-law left behind.

View on Amazon

Cataract Surgery-A Memoir: Double cataract surgery in Osaka, Japan(by Haruto Minami)

A record of going from blurring sight to surgery, checking things with my own eyes and not only on other people's word.

View on Amazon

Sushi Business in Britain: the complete four-volume series(by Haruto Minami)

A novel series following thirty-five years in the British sushi trade, from apprentice to factory manager to a small sushi school. The complete edition offers all four volumes at a better price.

About the Source

Speaker: Mr Yoshinori Kitano; Navigator: Sanyutei Rakusho Source: 'Power Game' by Direct Publishing (Japanese language) Original discussion: October 2026 issue, Part One, "World Affairs Behind the Headlines", "② A Leading MAGA Figure Turns Pro-Ukraine: Why?" (released on the 1st)

For details of Power Game, please see the summary page (Japanese language) and the table of contents (Japanese language).

I checked the news in this article against the following reports and sources.

About Yoshinori Kitano Kitano is an international relations analyst and the first Japanese graduate, with a master's degree in political science, of the Moscow State Institute of International Relations (MGIMO), attached to the Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs. He has continued to analyse world affairs through his newsletter, "Russia Political and Economic Journal." Website: rpejournal.com (Japanese language)

A book on Gareth Jones for English readers:

Gareth Jones: Eyewitness to the Holodomor (Ray Gamache, Welsh Academic Press, second edition, Kindle)

(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)