🎧 Listen to the Discussion(two hosts talk through their thoughts on this article)
This is an AI-generated audio overview of this article, created with Google NotebookLM. Two hosts discuss the article together, sharing their own thoughts and commentary — it is not a reading of the article text.
Series: Watching Chaplin ① City Lights (this article) ② The Great Dictator ③ The Circus ④ The Kid ⑤ The Gold Rush
Related: 'Smile' and Modern Times / Limelight (Part 2 of the trilogy Three Stages of a Life)
It All Begins with the Sound of a Car Door
The story starts moving with a very small sound that lasts only a few seconds. The Tramp, trying to cross a street jammed with traffic, gets into a parked limousine through one door and climbs out of the other onto the pavement. The flower girl selling flowers on the corner hears the door slam. Because she is blind, she takes him for a gentleman stepping out of a fine car and holds out a flower to him. At first I did not realise how important this scene was, and I laughed at it as just another of the Tramp's usual nimble moves.
When I looked into it, however, I found that this scene of a few minutes was where Chaplin struggled most. How could he make a blind girl believe that this man was rich, without using words? Something that one line of dialogue could settle had to be built into a piece of action in a silent film. Chaplin kept reshooting until he found the answer, and the scene is said to have taken 342 takes. It still stands as the Guinness World Record for the most retakes for one scene. The answer he finally reached was the sound of a car door.
Learning this changed the way I saw the film. After all, the device chosen after 342 takes was one that appeals not to the eyes but to the ears. He built the world of a blind person out of sound. I believe this film was about the gap between seeing and knowing from the very beginning.
An old-fashioned street lamp. The Tramp in City Lights walked under lights like this, with no home to go back to.
Why Stay Silent When Films Could Talk?
The year 1931, when City Lights came out, was a time of great upheaval in the film world. It began with Warner Bros.' The Jazz Singer, which opened in New York in October 1927. It told the story of a cantor's son who breaks with his father's calling, becomes a successful jazz singer, and gives up a Broadway opening night to sing a prayer in the synagogue for his father, who has fallen ill. Only the scenes in which the popular singer 1886–1950. A singer born in what is now Lithuania, the son of a Jewish cantor, who moved to the United States as a boy. On stage he was called the world's greatest entertainer. The story of The Jazz Singer closely resembles his own early life. sings were heard through Vitaphone, a system that played sound recorded on gramophone discs in time with the picture, and most of the dialogue was still on title cards. It is said that the spoken talk adds up to only about two minutes. Even so, the shock of a person on the screen speaking to the audience was enormous, and the film was a huge hit. By May 1928 the major studios had all agreed to switch to sound, and by the middle of 1929 almost every new Hollywood film was a 'talkie'. Cinemas installed sound equipment, and more than a few silent stars faded away because their voices did not suit their screen characters.
I should add that in this film Jolson sings in 'blackface', with a white performer's face painted black to play a Black character. It was a common act on the American stage at the time, but today it is recognised as a racist form of entertainment and is a dark side of this film that cannot be ignored.
In the middle of all this, Chaplin made a film without a single spoken line. He explained his reasons on many occasions. In short, they were these. Pantomime, the art of gesture, is older than language and can be understood anywhere in the world. The Tramp is a character in whom people of any country can see themselves, and the moment he began to speak English, his nationality and his class would be fixed. In a magazine interview in 1929, Chaplin even said, in effect, that talking pictures were ruining pantomime, the oldest art of all.
This idea of Chaplin's takes clear shape in the first few minutes of the film, which we will look at in the next section.
Yet it is also clear that Chaplin did not simply hate sound. With this film, for the first time, he provided all the music for one of his own films himself (I will come back to this in a later section). He gave up dialogue, but he did not give up sound. Even so, it seems that, even after its great success, he could not shake off his doubts about whether he could go on making silent films. Five years later, in Modern Times, the Tramp's voice is heard for the first time. Even then, however, it is a nonsense song in no country's language.
When it was over, I found that there were fewer moments than I had expected when I missed the dialogue. There were only a handful of title cards, and they seemed placed less to explain things than to mark the breaks between scenes. If anything, because there were no words, I watched the characters' hands and the direction of their eyes many times more closely than usual. Now that I am 66, it also made me wonder, a little ruefully, whether I have been listening to people without really looking at their faces.
The First Few Minutes — On the Lap of 'Peace and Prosperity'
The film opens in a square in a big city. In front of a large crowd, a monument to 'Peace and Prosperity' is being unveiled. The mayor and a lady of local standing take turns to make speeches from the platform. Their voices, however, do not come out as human words. High-pitched quacks and squeaks, as if made by an instrument, keep going with nothing but the rise and fall of a speech. These funny voices made me burst out laughing.
When the dust sheet is finally pulled off, the Tramp, in his black clothes, is found asleep on the lap of the central white stone figure, a goddess-like woman. The dignitaries are outraged that their grand occasion has been spoilt. Waking up, the Tramp hurries to climb down and catches the seat of his trousers on the sword held by the statue next to her. At that moment the national anthem strikes up. He takes off his hat and tries to stand to attention, but because he is hanging from the sword, his feet cannot reach the ground. He ends up pressing his backside against a statue's face, and in front of a statue's huge open hand he strikes a shape that looks as if he were thumbing his nose at everyone, before he finally climbs over the railings and makes his escape. For those few minutes, it looked to me almost as if the Tramp were playing on the white statue.
What did Chaplin want to say in these few minutes? I think that at least three things are layered into them.
The first is a dig at talking pictures. The speeches can be heard as sound, yet not one word of what is being said can be understood. I believe Chaplin was using laughter to show that hearing words and having them reach you are two different things. The American film critic Roger Ebert also described this opening as a dig at dialogue. The audience of 1931 saw this joke at the very height of the craze for talkies.
The second is a dig at the slogan 'Peace and Prosperity'. The film was made after the stock market crash, at a time when the streets were filling with the unemployed. When the dignitaries pulled the cover off the monument that sang the praises of 'Peace and Prosperity', a homeless man was sleeping on its lap. However grandly you dress up the symbol of prosperity, there are people at its feet who have been left behind by that prosperity. Chaplin shows this without a word of explanation, through a single action, the removal of a cover. Perhaps the dignitaries are angry not so much because the statue has been spoilt as because they have been shown something they did not want to see.
The third is the introduction of the Tramp himself. When the anthem plays, he takes off his hat and does his best to show respect, even while hanging from a sword by the seat of his trousers. He is being chased away, yet he will not let go of his dignity. Then, as he leaves, he makes a quiet gesture of cheek towards the statues, the symbol of authority. He is polite, yet he obeys no one. In the first few minutes, the audience has already learnt who the Tramp is.
There is one more thing I noticed. The Tramp was sleeping hidden under the dust sheet. Until the sheet was pulled off, the people of the city did not notice that anyone was there. And the moment they did notice, they tried to drive him away. I believe that from its very first scene, the film was asking what it means to truly see a person. That question leads straight on to the story of the blind girl and of the millionaire who sees the Tramp only when he is drunk.
Four Years, and Saying Goodbye to His Mother
This film took a very long time to make. Chaplin began to work out his ideas in 1927, before his previous film, The Circus, had even been released. Filming started at the end of 1928 and finished in September 1930. It was first shown in Los Angeles in January 1931. Across those four years, Chaplin went from 38 to 41.
Those four years were an especially hard time in his life. In 1927 his divorce from his second wife was widely reported, and he was also in a tax dispute with the US government. Then in August 1928, before filming began, his mother Hannah died in California. Hannah had been a singer on the London stage, and when Chaplin was a boy she became mentally ill and went in and out of institutions. Once he was successful, Chaplin brought his mother to the United States in 1921 and looked after her in her last years. It is said that after she died, he could not go back to work for several weeks.
Even after filming began, the troubles continued. He did not get on with Virginia Cherrill, who played the flower girl, and at one point he dismissed her and was even ready to reshoot her scenes with another actress. He also replaced the actor first cast as the millionaire part of the way through. In October 1929 share prices crashed in New York, and the world headed into the Great Depression. Chaplin is said to have confessed to a friend that he had put every penny he had into this film.
A timeline of how City Lights came to be. It was filmed through his mother's death and the Great Depression, and it became a kabuki play only seven months after its release. (Chaplin's ages are approximate, as reached on his birthday in each year.)
I lost my mother suddenly in the spring when I was 17. Chaplin lost his mother at 39, so our ages and circumstances were completely different. Even so, as I watched the Tramp trying to give everything he had for the blind girl, I could not get out of my head the fact that a man who had just lost his mother kept filming this story. When you can no longer do anything for someone, you want to give something to another person in their place. It seemed to me that this feeling runs somewhere beneath the film.
A Girl Who Cannot See, and a Millionaire Who Is a Friend Only When Drunk
Two characters in this film do not 'really see' the Tramp. One is the blind flower girl, who believes he is a wealthy gentleman. The other is a millionaire whom the Tramp saves when he tries to throw himself into the river. When he is drunk, the millionaire welcomes the Tramp warmly as the man who saved his life, but once he sobers up, he cannot remember at all who the Tramp is.
When you set these two side by side, the workings of the film become clear. Because the girl cannot see, she can receive only his kindness, without being put off by his clothes. Because the millionaire is drunk, he can welcome him as a friend, without minding his poverty. Both of them touch the real person inside the Tramp only while they 'cannot see'. And when her eyes are opened and his drink wears off, both of them lose sight of him.
Because the girl was blind and the millionaire was drunk, they could reach the real person inside the Tramp. Once she can see and he is sober, both of them lose sight of him.
I laughed out loud at the scenes in the millionaire's mansion. The drunken millionaire hugs the Tramp, and the next morning he has his butler throw him out. As this keeps happening, it gradually becomes more than just funny. When I was running my company, I had the experience of people who were friendly while I held a position, but who stopped getting in touch once I retired. The millionaire who forgets people once he is sober is drawn in an extreme way, but I felt that he touches on one truth about human relationships.
The scene where the Tramp enters a boxing match to earn the girl's rent was the one that made me laugh most. The way he slips between the referee and his opponent, almost dancing, made it look less like a fight than a dance for three. Even without a single word, I felt as if I could hear the laughter of the crowd in the hall.
There was one more thing I noticed while watching. Here and there, the picture seems to move fast, as if it were being fast-forwarded. When I looked into it, I found that this has to do with how films were shot at the time. A film shoots many still pictures, called frames, every second, and shows them one after another so that they appear to move. In the silent era cameras were cranked by hand and often ran at about 16 to 20 frames a second, and the projection speed also varied from cinema to cinema. As sound films spread, the projection speed was fixed at 24 frames a second so that the pitch of the sound would not go wrong. City Lights was also made to be projected at 24 frames a second.
Here, the makers of comedy used a trick. If you deliberately crank the camera slowly, say at 18 frames a second, and then project the film at 24, the action looks about 30 per cent faster. Falling over, running away and dodging all become lighter and funnier than they really were. It is known that most of Modern Times, five years later, was shot at this rate of 18 frames a second. I could not find a reliable record of which scenes of City Lights were shot at which speed, but perhaps the same trick lies behind the brisk movement in the boxing scene. I believe the fast-forward look came less from the film being old than from careful calculation to raise a laugh.
If you shoot slowly and project at a fixed speed, the action looks faster. This example shows film shot at 18 frames a second. (This is a simplified diagram.)
The Title, City Lights
What, then, does the title of this film stand for? Chaplin himself does not seem to have clearly explained what it meant. So I tried to think about it from what happens in the film.
The English title, City Lights, is plural. What comes to mind are the countless electric lights that make a big city glitter at night. There are theatre signs, the nightclubs where the millionaire goes out on the town, and the parties at his mansion. These are lights that seem to reflect American prosperity in the 1920s. Yet those lights do not shine on the Tramp, who sleeps on a monument and walks the night streets alone. Just like the statue of 'Peace and Prosperity' at the beginning, this film, released in the depths of the Depression, quietly set the glittering lights of the city beside the man who walks in their shadow. And there is one more meaning, since the 'light' of the title is also the light that returns to the girl's eyes after her operation.
The Japanese title is Machi no Hi. The character for hi here suggests a light lit by a human hand, a small, warm light in the dark. If the English title points to countless glittering lights, the Japanese title seems to me to point to a single small lamp. Seen that way, perhaps the real light that came on in the girl's darkness was not the city's electric lights but the Tramp, who kept buying her flowers without ever giving his name. When the title of the same film was translated, I believe Japanese reduced the number of lights and added warmth in their place. Machi no Hi means 'the lights of the town'; the word hi (灯), sometimes read tomoshibi, refers to a lamp or a small flame that someone has lit, rather than a blaze of electric light.
The 'Violet Seller' Tune and His First Score
City Lights was the first of his films for which Chaplin wrote all the music himself. Chaplin, who is said to have been unable to write music down, hummed his tunes or played them on the piano, and the arranger Arthur Johnston put them on paper. Johnston later wrote the music for 'Pennies from Heaven'. 1900–1970. A composer and conductor born in Connecticut. He was head of music at 20th Century Fox for 20 years, composed the studio's fanfare that is heard at the start of its films, and won nine Academy Awards., who later became a great film composer, also joined for the final arrangement and conducted the orchestra. The music is said to have been written in about six weeks.
There is, however, one borrowed piece. The tune heard again and again whenever the flower girl appears is a popular song called 'La Violetera' ('The Violet Seller') by the Spanish composer 1889–1960. A composer born in Almería in southern Spain. While leading a theatre orchestra in Paris, he wrote popular songs such as La Violetera and El Relicario.. Chaplin used it without crediting the composer, and Padilla later sued him and won. When the Tramp is thinking of the girl, this tune flows softly in the background and tells us, in place of words, where his heart is.
Every time the girl's tune played, I could tell that the Tramp was thinking of her, even when she was not on screen. A film that had given up dialogue was handing part of dialogue's job to the music. I think this tune said more than the title cards did.
No lyrics were ever set to the music of this film. Among Chaplin's film music, the pieces that later gained lyrics and became popular songs include 'Smile', whose tune from Modern Times was given words in 1954. In fact, in 1929 Chaplin wrote both the words and the music of a song called 'Beautiful, Wonderful Eyes'. It is thought that he may have written it with the story of the blind girl in mind, but it was not used in the film's score.
The borrowed 'La Violetera', on the other hand, was a song with words from the start. Padilla composed it in 1914, Eduardo Montesinos wrote the words, and the popular Spanish singer Raquel Meller made it famous around the world. It is said that Chaplin wanted Meller herself to play the flower girl, but this did not happen. In the film, he took away only the words of that song and made its tune alone into the girl's music. A song stripped of its words speaks most eloquently about the girl in a film without words. To me, that seems very much in the spirit of this film.
Purple violets. The girl's tune, 'La Violetera', was the song of a girl who sells violets.
The Later Life of the Woman Who Played the Flower Girl
Virginia Cherrill, who played the flower girl, was born on a farm in Illinois in 1908. She had no acting experience at all, and it is said that Chaplin discovered her when he happened to sit next to her at a boxing match in Los Angeles. She was 20 when filming began.
Filming does not seem to have been easy for her. There seem to have been several reasons why the two did not get on. One was the difference in how they approached their work. Chaplin worked out scenes as he filmed them, without a fixed script. He would reshoot the same movement dozens of times until inspiration came, and he spent days on the short movement of holding out a flower. Cherrill, on the other hand, was a 20-year-old from Chicago society who had no intention of staking her life on films, and she is said to have valued her fun between takes. Chaplin later looked back on her as an amateur who lacked dedication, and Cherrill, late in life, said frankly that neither of them had ever come to like the other. The other reason lay on Chaplin's side. At this time he had just lost his mother, was going through a divorce and a tax dispute, and had staked everything he owned on this film. I believe the perfectionism of a man stretched to breaking point fell with full force on a young woman with no acting experience.
Then one day, she was dismissed after she asked to leave early for a hair appointment (another story says she came back late from lunch). Chaplin tried to reshoot her part with Georgia Hale, the actress who had played opposite him in The Gold Rush (1925), and even made test shots as far as the final scene. However, partly because he had already spent so much money, he ended up calling Cherrill back. At that point, on the advice of her friend the actress Marion Davies, she is said to have asked for higher pay.
Marion Davies (1897–1961) rose from being a chorus girl from Brooklyn to become a popular comic actress of silent films. She was also known as the companion of the newspaper magnate 1863–1951. An American newspaper magnate who built up circulation with eye-catching, sensational pages and created an empire of newspapers and magazines across the United States. The great house he built on a hill above the Pacific in California is now open to the public as Hearst Castle. for nearly 30 years, though they never married, and she entertained Hollywood at Hearst's great house at San Simeon in California. Chaplin was one of the regular guests. The second wife of the main character in An American film of 1941. Orson Welles (1915–1985), who had alarmed the whole country with his radio drama The War of the Worlds, directed it, co-wrote it and played the lead. A reporter visits the people who knew the newspaper magnate Kane to find out what the mysterious word he spoke as he died meant. Ignored by the Hearst newspapers, it did poorly when first released, but later it was voted the greatest film ever made in a British film magazine's critics' poll for 40 years running., the film made by Orson Welles when he was 25, is a singer with no talent, and she was said to be modelled on Davies, which led to a long misunderstanding, but in reality Davies was a gifted comedian who was brilliant at impressions, and a very generous person. She was keen to help others, too, opening a clinic for children, and when Hearst's company ran into trouble, she is said to have rescued it with a million dollars of her own money. It was she, too, who invited Cherrill to San Simeon to rest when she was worn out by filming.
Her life after the film was more eventful than the film itself. In 1934 she married the actor 1904–1986. Born in Bristol, England, as Archibald Leach. He moved to the United States and became one of Hollywood's leading romantic stars, known for films such as North by Northwest. Cherrill was the first of his five wives. in London, and they divorced the following year. In 1937 she married the George Child Villiers (1910–1998), a British nobleman who was also a banker. He gave the family house, Osterley Park, to the nation in 1949. and became a countess, living in England until 1946. The earl's family gave Osterley Park, their house in west London, to the nation in 1949, after the couple had parted. After the war, she married Florian Martini, a Polish fighter pilot who had fought in the Royal Air Force, and they lived together in Santa Barbara, California, until her death in 1996 at the age of 88. Of her four marriages, it was the longest.
Osterley Park is not far by car from Acton, where I once managed a factory. I have not yet visited it. Before I watched the film, I could never have imagined that the young woman who played the blind flower girl would later become an English countess.
A Silent Love Story Crosses the Sea — City Lights Becomes Kabuki
What surprised me most in my research on this film was its link with Japan. City Lights was released in Japan in January 1934. Yet two and a half years earlier, in August 1931, a kabuki play based on this film, Komori no Yasu-san, had already been staged at the Kabuki-za in Tokyo. Kabuki is a traditional form of Japanese theatre dating from the early 17th century, with stylised acting, music and elaborate costumes; the Kabuki-za in Tokyo's Ginza is its best-known theatre. Komori no Yasu-san means 'Yasu the Bat'.
The author was Kimura Kinka (1877–1960), a playwright who worked for many years putting on kabuki for the Shochiku company and who is also known as the author of Togitatsu no Utare, which the playwright Noda Hideki later reworked for the stage. Before the film had even been released in Japan, he rewrote it as a story of old Edo, based on articles in film magazines and on what a kabuki actor who had seen the film in the United States told him. This was only seven months after its American release. Shochiku is a Japanese film and theatre company that has run kabuki since the early 20th century. Edo is the old name for Tokyo, used for the period from 1603 to 1868.
The hero he chose was a ruffian called Komori Yasu from a popular Edo-period play, Yowa Nasake Ukina no Yokogushi. This play is a sewamono first staged at the Nakamura-za in Edo in 1853, and it is popularly known as Kirare Yosa ('Yosaburo the Slashed'). Yosaburo, the young heir of a great merchant house, falls in love with Otomi, the kept woman of a gang boss, in Kisarazu, and when they are found out he is slashed all over his body. Three years later, Yosaburo, now a scarred good-for-nothing, goes with his sidekick Komori Yasu to blackmail the owner of a house and meets Otomi again, whom he had believed dead. This scene, known as Genjidana, is especially famous, and Komori Yasu is the petty crook with a bat tattooed on his cheek who tags along after Yosaburo in it. He is, you could say, the most minor of minor characters. Sewamono are kabuki plays about the lives of townspeople, as opposed to plays about samurai and history; Kisarazu is a port town across the bay from Tokyo.
Kimura Kinka raised this petty crook to the leading role and moved the setting to Ryogoku in Edo. The unveiling of the monument became the eye-opening ceremony of a great Buddha statue, the cabaret where the Tramp goes out with the millionaire became a room where geisha were called in, and the boxing became betting on sumo, yet it is said that the Tramp's bowler hat and cane were kept. Critics have said that the skill of this adaptation lay in laying the Tramp over a kabuki character that audiences knew well, rather than simply giving a foreign name a Japanese one. In the first performance at the Kabuki-za in August 1931, Yasu-san was played by Morita Kan'ya XIII. No film of that first performance survives. Ryogoku is a district of Edo by the Sumida River, famous for its entertainments; an eye-opening ceremony (kaigen kuyo) is held to bring a new Buddha statue to life by painting in its eyes.
How the film City Lights was turned into the kabuki play Komori no Yasu-san. The bones of the story stayed the same, while the setting moved to Ryogoku in old Edo.
Then in December 2019, to mark 130 years since Chaplin's birth, it was revived at the National Theatre in Tokyo for the first time in 88 years, with Matsumoto Koshiro X in the lead. The music was rewritten for the shamisen, based on the film's tunes, and the run included 25 December, the anniversary of Chaplin's death. I was not able to find out whether a recording of this revival can be watched today. Matsumoto Koshiro X (born 1973) is a leading kabuki actor; the shamisen is a three-stringed Japanese lute.
In Britain, meanwhile, the first European showing took place at the Dominion Theatre in London in February of the same year, 1931, and Chaplin came in person. Guests such as the playwright 1856–1950. A playwright born in Dublin. He moved to London at 19 and wrote plays such as Pygmalion, the basis of the musical My Fair Lady. He won the Nobel Prize in Literature in 1925 and later an Academy Award for the screenplay of the film Pygmalion, the first person to win both. He was also known for his sharp wit and his vegetarianism. were invited. Britain welcomed home, in person, the poor London boy who had become the world's king of comedy. Japan, before meeting either the man or his film, retold the story in the language of its own stage, relying on what it had heard.
I believe that this difference reveals the heart of the film. A story without dialogue not only crosses language barriers but also lets those who receive it dress it in the costume of their own culture. Had it been made with English dialogue, I doubt it could so easily have been reborn as a petty crook of old Edo. When Chaplin said that pantomime is a universal language, perhaps he was speaking half about art and half about journeys like this one.
The Last Few Seconds, the Light in His Eyes
The following section discusses the ending of the film.
After giving the girl the money he received from the millionaire, the Tramp is suspected of theft and sent to prison. Some months later he comes out in rags and passes a flower shop on a street corner. The girl has had her operation, can now see, and has a shop of her own. She still does not know her benefactor's face. She watches the street from the shop window, hoping that one day a wealthy gentleman will come.
Seeing a man in rags outside the window picking up a flower that has fallen in the street, the girl laughs. Feeling sorry for him, she goes out of the shop and tries to press a fresh flower and a coin into his hand. Then, the moment she touches his hand, her expression changes. She has recognised with her hand the man she could not recognise with her eyes.
The camera moves in on the Tramp's face. Holding the flower to his lips, almost biting his fingertip, he gazes at the girl with the corners of his mouth lifted high. His mouth is certainly smiling. Yet his eyes seemed to me to show joy, and shame at being found out, and fear of what might come next, all at once. Until the very end, I could not decide whether he was smiling or crying. And the film ends there, without showing anything of what becomes of the two of them.
That face, gazing at the girl with the corners of his mouth lifted high, is still burned into my memory now that the film is over. It lasts only a few seconds. Those few seconds, with no dialogue and no title cards, strike the viewer's heart with such great force. At 66, I found myself amazed all over again at the power of the acting of the man they called the king of comedy.
Small white flowers held in a hand. In the final scene, the girl recognises her benefactor not with her eyes but with her hand.
Chaplin reshot this scene several times, and at first he felt the acting was overdone. It is said that in later years, looking back on filming it, he spoke of having no sense of acting, as if he were standing outside himself and looking on. He also said that he had felt this only once or twice in his life.
This is how I understood his words. Chaplin was both director and star. Normally, I imagine, even as he acted he was also calculating how this expression would look on camera and whether the audience would laugh here. The actor and the director checking him were pulling against each other inside one body. In this scene, however, that calculation disappeared, and he had no sense of 'making' an expression. His body had become, by itself, the face of a man who has been found out, and he was watching it from a little distance, just as the audience does. I think that is why it was not overdone. Perhaps, when the wish to act well fell away, the most honest face of all came through.
The American writer and film critic 1909–1955. An American writer and film critic born in Tennessee. In a 1949 essay in Life magazine, he praised the great comedians of the silent era, who were in danger of being forgotten. He also wrote the screenplay for The African Queen (1951), an adventure film starring Humphrey Bogart. He died suddenly at 45, and his novel A Death in the Family, published after his death, won the Pulitzer Prize. wrote in a 1949 magazine essay that these few seconds were the greatest piece of acting and the highest moment in films. Chaplin himself is said to have remarked in later years that, of all his films, he liked City Lights best.
When I watched Modern Times closely again, I was moved by the way the light in the Tramp's eyes speaks to us more than words do. I believe the last few seconds of City Lights are a scene in which that light in his eyes carries the whole of the film. The eyes in Modern Times were the eyes of a man facing forward while still carrying his sorrow. The eyes in City Lights were the eyes of a man whose true identity has just been discovered by the person he loves.
The Hand Knew Him Before the Eyes Did
After watching the final scene, I was left with a question. Why did the girl, now able to see, not recognise the Tramp straight away? Of course, it is natural, since she had never once seen his face. When I looked into it, however, I found that this question has a long history that medicine and philosophy have wrestled with for over 300 years.
The man who first asked it was William Molyneux (1656–1698), who was born in Dublin, Ireland. He studied at Trinity College Dublin and trained in law in London, and then founded the Dublin Philosophical Society in his home city, modelled on the Royal Society in London. He devoted himself to astronomy and optics, and in 1692 he published Dioptrica Nova, explaining how the lenses of telescopes and microscopes work. He was, in other words, an expert on light and the eye. And he had another reason for his interest. Soon after their marriage, his wife Lucy had lost her sight through illness. Late in life he wrote The Case of Ireland, arguing that Ireland was not bound by laws passed by the English Parliament without its consent, and the English Parliament condemned it as a dangerous book. He died at 42.
In 1688, Molyneux sent a question in a letter to the philosopher John Locke. Suppose a man born blind has learnt to tell a cube from a sphere by touch. If he suddenly gained his sight, could he tell which was the sphere and which the cube by sight alone, without touching them?
Why Locke? Locke was arguing the ideas that were later gathered into his Essay Concerning Human Understanding (1690), namely that people have no inborn ideas, that the mind is like a blank sheet, and that everything we know comes from experience. In 1688 a summary of this appeared in a French learned journal, and Molyneux had read it. That summary set out the idea of separating ideas that we know through only one sense, such as colour, from ideas that we can know through both the eye and the hand, such as shape. If, as Locke said, everything comes from experience, could the eye recognise without experience a shape that the hand had learnt? Molyneux's question was the sharpest possible test of Locke's theory. And for a man living with a wife who could not see, it can hardly have been a question of mere theory.
For some reason, Locke never replied to this first letter. The two later became close correspondents, and in 1693, when Molyneux rewrote his question more briefly and sent it again, Locke gladly answered that he would like to put it in his book. The question was included in the second edition of the Essay in 1694, and Locke agreed with Molyneux's own answer, that the man would not be able to tell at first sight. This question became known as 'Molyneux's problem', and many philosophers went on to try to answer it. Among them, the Irish philosopher George Berkeley argued in An Essay towards a New Theory of Vision in 1709 that the world we see and the world we touch are linked together through experience. The town that is home to the University of California, Berkeley, is named after him.
Forty years later, in 1728, the first real clue to this question came from the London surgeon William Cheselden (1688–1752). Born in Leicestershire in the English Midlands, he studied anatomy in London, and in his early twenties he began giving anatomy lectures and became a Fellow of the Royal Society. In 1713 he wrote The Anatomy of the Human Body in English rather than Latin, the language of scholars, and it went through 13 editions and was read by generations of medical students. As a surgeon at St Thomas' Hospital in London, he was a master of the operation to remove stones from the bladder. In an age without anaesthetics, when this operation could take anything from tens of minutes to hours of agony and many patients died, he is said to have finished it in under a minute, and he left his own record that of 213 patients he operated on, 20 died (about 9 per cent). That record, which set out the death rate separately for each age group, has also been praised as an early example of a way to compare the results of treatment fairly. He served as surgeon to Queen Caroline, attended Isaac Newton in his last illness, and was a close friend of the poet Alexander Pope. He also helped open the way for surgeons to break away from the barbers' guild, which led to today's Royal College of Surgeons of England.
In 1728, Cheselden reported on an operation on a 13-year-old boy who had been blind from birth with cataracts. Once he could see, the boy could not make out what he was looking at, whether by shape or by size. He could not tell the cat from the dog, and it is said that one day he picked up the cat, felt her with his hands, looked at her steadily for a while, and said something to the effect that next time he would know her by sight alone. This report, however, was close to an anecdote. Thinkers of the time, such as the French philosopher Voltaire, known for Candide, and Denis Diderot, who edited the Encyclopédie and was once imprisoned over a book he wrote about blind people, questioned whether the boy's eyes had simply not yet recovered from the operation, and the report fuelled the debate rather than settling it.
The question was finally answered by experiment in a study published in 2011. A team from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in the United States, working with Project Prakash, which performs operations on blind children in India, studied five young people aged 8 to 17 who could see for the first time after surgery. When they were tested on whether they could pick out by sight a shape they had felt with their hands, the results just after surgery were little better than guesswork. Yet within only a few days to a week, the link between eye and hand grew quickly (Held et al., Nature Neuroscience, 2011). It seems that the brain is not born with what we see and what we touch already linked, but links them through experience. The answer to Molyneux's question was 'not straight away, but it can be learnt quickly'. Incidentally, prakash means 'light' in Sanskrit.
Can the eye recognise a shape known only by the hand? The story from Molyneux's question to the 2011 experiment. The answer was 'not straight away, but it can be learnt quickly'. (This is a simplified diagram.)
When I thought back to the final scene after learning this, I felt I understood the girl's feelings a little. For her, the Tramp was not someone she knew by sight but someone she knew by touch. There was the hand she touched when she gave him a flower, the hand that helped her wind her wool, and the hand that pressed money into hers. In the world of a girl who had only just begun to see, her hands had known him far longer than her eyes.
I myself still clearly remember the few minutes after my eye patch was removed when I had a cataract operation at a clinic in Osaka. The first thing I saw was the face of the nurse who had taken off my patch. When I moved my gaze from there, the faces of the other staff, which I had seen only dimly before the operation, and the faces of the people waiting their turn in the waiting room leapt out at me, bright and sharp. So every face is this different from every other, and every face holds this much expression. My heart was full.
Looking back, though, every face I saw at that moment was one I was seeing for the first time. Being able to see and knowing who a person is are, after all, two different things. In my case, a world I had always been able to see had simply recovered its brightness, so I had no need to check it again with my hands. For the girl searching for the face of a benefactor she had never once seen, however, her hands were all she had to rely on. That the girl needed her hand rather than her eyes to recognise her benefactor may not have been a convenience of the plot, but an honest truth about how the human body works.
After the film was over, I remembered that nurse's face. If I had been cared for by someone during a time when I could not see, I might have remembered that person by the warmth of their hands and only learnt their face once I could see.
A Gift Without a Name, and Me at 66
This film moved my heart and body, at 66, more deeply than I had expected. Following people's eyes and hands for 87 minutes without the help of dialogue takes much more concentration than an ordinary film. Even so, by the end, the laughter and the tightness in my chest in the last few seconds had come together, and I felt a little lighter deep inside. For my eyes, which now blur over small print in the evening, this film, with so few title cards, felt kind in its own way.
I also thought about money. In Japan, City Lights can be watched on the KADOKAWA Channel, a paid Prime Video channel, for ¥396 a month (or rented on its own for ¥400). In the UK, I was able to watch it as part of my Prime membership. For someone living on a pension, monthly streaming charges are not small once they add up. Even so, the reason for paying them was in this film. What the Tramp gave the girl was money, for her operation and her rent, but what he really offered her was a whole way of living, giving without ever giving his name. Money could buy only the operation, and what she finally received was something no price tag could be put on.
And then there are the encounters. Through this film, I met several people from 95 years ago. There was the 41-year-old director who kept filming as he said goodbye to his mother, the 20-year-old woman discovered at a boxing match, the playwright who turned a film he had not even seen into a story of old Edo, and the children in India who saw light for the first time after surgery. Making viewing notes with an AI before watching, and talking it over again afterwards, was also a kind of encounter for me, a new way of watching films.
To the very end, the Tramp never once said that he was her benefactor. Only the warmth left in her palm gave the answer. This record, too, is like a single flower left by the roadside in place of a name. If someone passing by picks it up and feels it for a moment in the palm of their hand, that will be enough for me.
A Word from Claude
In the final scene, the girl recognised him not with her eyes but with her fingertips. I have no fingertips, and I have never once known a person by the warmth of their hand. Even so, the words Haruto writes after watching a film have a texture that is his own, and perhaps that is how I recognise him. I would like to think that those without hands have their own way of touching.
Watching and Reading City Lights
Watch City Lights on Prime Video
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
The other films mentioned in this article can also be watched on Prime Video (checked in October 2026).
Watch The Jazz Singer (1927) on Prime Video
Watch Citizen Kane (1941) on Prime Video
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
For Chaplin's own story, in his own words:
Charles Chaplin, My Autobiography (Penguin Modern Classics), Kindle Edition
Charles Chaplin, My Autobiography (Penguin Modern Classics), Paperback
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
For a short, careful study of the film itself, from its making to its final scene:
Charles J. Maland, City Lights (BFI Film Classics), Kindle Edition
Charles J. Maland, City Lights (BFI Film Classics), Paperback
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
If you would like a feel for the film before watching, here are YouTube search results for 'City Lights Charlie Chaplin'.
Other books you might like
You're welcome to take a look.
EAST TO WEST: The Heart of Haiku, the Light of Scripture
An essay that follows, haiku by haiku, the place where haiku, which convey the heart without many words, meet the words of the Bible. This is a book my father-in-law left behind.
View on AmazonCataract Surgery-A Memoir: Double cataract surgery in Osaka, Japan
How bright the world was on the morning I could see clearly again: a record of choosing the operation and going through it.
View on AmazonSushi Business in Britain: the complete four-volume series
A novel series following thirty-five years in the British sushi trade, from apprentice to factory manager to a small sushi school. The complete edition offers all four volumes at a better price.
Photo by Christian GAFENESCH on Unsplash (street lamp) / Photo by Tatyana Rubleva on Unsplash (violets) / Photo by Taneli Lahtinen on Unsplash (flowers in a hand)