🎧 Listen to the Discussion(two hosts talk through their thoughts on this article)
This is an AI-generated audio overview of this article, created with Google NotebookLM. Two hosts discuss the article together, sharing their own thoughts and commentary — it is not a reading of the article text.
Series: Watching Chaplin ① City Lights ② The Great Dictator ③ The Circus (this article) ④ The Kid ⑤ The Gold Rush
Related articles: 'Smile' and Modern Times / Limelight
The Story of The Circus (Up to the Ending)
The hero is the usual tramp with his bowler hat and cane. Still hungry, he is wandering around the fairground of a travelling circus. There, a pickpocket suddenly slips a stolen wallet and watch into the tramp's pocket. Chased by both a policeman and the pickpocket, the tramp runs through a maze of mirrors and a sideshow full of mechanical figures. The place he finally tumbles into is the very centre of the big top, in the middle of a performance. The magician's act is thrown into chaos, but the audience, thinking the chase is a new act, roars with laughter.
The ringmaster, who has been worried because the crowds are thin, wonders whether he could use this man as a clown. Yet at the tryout the next day, the more the tramp copies the routines he is taught, the less funny he becomes. He is sent away at first, but when the stagehands walk out in anger over unpaid wages, the tramp is taken on as a property man. Each time he carries props into the ring he causes chaos, and each time the audience erupts. The ringmaster keeps him at the side of the ring on low pay, without ever letting him realise this.
In the company there is Merna, the ringmaster's stepdaughter, who performs on horseback. When her act goes badly, she is made to go without food. The tramp shares his own food with her, and the two become close. In time, Merna tells him that he is the one the audience comes to see. The tramp confronts the ringmaster, gets his treatment improved, and puts a stop to the cruel way Merna is treated. He also runs into danger, such as being shut in a lion's cage when he hides there, but the two slowly grow closer.
One day, from a hiding place, the tramp overhears a fortune-teller telling Merna about the man she will marry. Believing it means him, he buys a ring from another clown. But just then, Rex, a newly hired tightrope walker, arrives, and Merna falls for him at first sight. Downcast, the tramp can no longer raise a laugh in the ring either, and the ringmaster warns him that one more failure will cost him his job.
The tramp secretly begins to practise on the tightrope. Then, one evening, Rex is nowhere to be seen when it is time for his act, and the ringmaster sends the tramp up onto the high wire in his place.
What happens next, I will come to in the section on the ending.
Watching It, and What Stayed with Me First
I watched it on the television in the living room of our house in the UK. It runs for about an hour and ten minutes, so unlike The Great Dictator I did not need to split it over two nights, and I finished it in one evening.
When it ended, my first thought was that this is a film about laughter and, at the same time, a film that thinks about what laughter is while making us laugh. With this third film, I felt for the first time that I was seeing Chaplin take his own trade, the work of a clown, as his subject.
There are three reasons why I think so.
The first is the story itself. In City Lights the tramp works for the sake of a flower girl, and in The Great Dictator Chaplin played a barber. In The Circus, however, the tramp is hired by a circus, and making the audience laugh becomes his job. What is more, the film shows us, one step at a time, through the tryout and through the old clowns whose acts the audience has grown tired of, what makes an audience laugh and what does not. It is a film that shows the dressing room of the people who make us laugh, while making us laugh.
The second is where Chaplin himself started. Both his parents were performers in the London music halls, the popular theatres of songs and sketches, and Chaplin too was on the stage from childhood. From the end of 1900 to the spring of the following year, the eleven-year-old Chaplin appeared in Cinderella at the London Hippodrome, playing a cat. This was a large theatre with a circus ring, and its star was the Spanish-born clown A Spanish-born clown (died 1927). He became the star of the London Hippodrome, and from 1905 he appeared at the New York Hippodrome, where he was a favourite for about ten years. His popularity later faded, and in his last years he was out of work. (Wikipedia: Marceline Orbes). Later, in his autobiography, Chaplin described this clown's act in detail. The circus ring was one of the first places Chaplin looked up to as a performer.
The third is the timing. Marceline, whose popularity faded as the times moved on, found less and less work, and in November 1927 he died in a hotel room in New York. It was when Chaplin was putting the finishing touches to The Circus. Watching the clowns in the film, who can only perform old routines and whom the audience has grown tired of, I cannot help thinking of what became of the clown the boy Chaplin once looked up to. Even so, I could find no record that Chaplin had Marceline in mind when he made this film. This is my own imagining.
The Original Meaning of Dōke and "Clown"
There is no settled view on where the Japanese word for a clown, dōke, comes from. Dictionaries and encyclopaedias list several theories: that it is a corruption of odoke or tawake, that it comes from dōgi, meaning children's play, or that it comes from the name of a retainer of the warlord Saito Dosan (Kotobank: "dōke", Japanese language). In kabuki, the role of making people laugh is called dōkegata, and its short form, dōke, already appears in a book of actor reviews from 1674. What I found interesting in one encyclopaedia's explanation was that it describes the clown's task as someone who criticises the fixed order of the world through clowning and loosens the frames through which we see things. Odoke means playful antics and tawake means foolishness. Saito Dosan (c. 1494–1556) was a warlord of the Sengoku, or Warring States, period. Kabuki is Japan's classical popular theatre, and dōkegata is the name of its comic role.
The English word "clown" was even more of a surprise. According to an English etymological dictionary, the word first appears in English in the 1560s, and its original meaning was "a rustic, a boor". Going back further still, it is thought to have been a word for "a clod, a lump". The sense of "clown" as a profession, someone who makes people laugh, was added only from around 1600.
In other words, a clown was originally a clumsy outsider who did not fit in with the manners of the town. Seen this way, the tramp was already a clown in the original sense of the word before the circus ever hired him. He is a clumsy outsider in a bowler hat and baggy trousers, with no place to belong, forever being chased by the police. That man then becomes a professional clown inside the ring. I believe The Circus is a film in which the two meanings of the word "clown" come together in one man. And in the way the tramp, who knows no set routines, makes the audience laugh more than the old clowns who follow them, I felt I could also see the clown's original task of loosening frames.
The Opening Song: Who Is Singing, and What About?
The film begins with Merna swinging high on a trapeze while a man's voice sings over the picture. The song is called "Swing Little Girl", and it was both written and sung by Chaplin himself (listen on YouTube Music).
However, this song was not there when the film was released in 1928, and it was added some forty years later. This is because, in the silent era, music was something played live in the cinema by an orchestra or a pianist.
According to an article on the official Chaplin website, a professional singer was booked for the recording, but Eric James, who helped with the arrangement, advised recording Chaplin himself, since he was always singing the song. In this way, the version sung by Chaplin himself at seventy-nine was used in the film. The song speaks to a girl swinging high on the trapeze, telling her not to keep looking down at her feet but to raise her eyes and search the sky.
Listening to the slightly husky voice of an old man, I thought that this was the voice of someone who, after forty years, had at last been able to face the work from the most painful time of his life. When he tells a young girl to lift her head, perhaps he was also speaking to himself at seventy-nine. Why this film belonged to "the most painful time", I will explain in the sections that follow.
In the Hall of Mirrors, Why Does the Tramp Multiply?
The film's first great commotion takes place in the hall of mirrors at the fair. The tramp, the pickpocket and the policeman keep bumping into their own reflections and can no longer tell which one is real. The scene in which many Chaplins appear across the screen is so elaborate that it is hard to believe it is a silent film, and I could not help rewinding to watch it again.
The many tramps in the mirrors also look to me like a picture of how the man who had become the most famous clown in the world saw his own image.
This is because, by the time this film was made, the tramp's figure no longer belonged to Chaplin alone. According to the official Chaplin website, by the mid-1910s a craze had broken out that the newspapers called "Chaplinitis": fancy-dress balls were full of men with bowler hats and toothbrush moustaches, and imitators on stage, fake "Chaplin films" and even lookalike contests appeared all over Britain and America. In 1917 there was even a man who committed a robbery dressed as the tramp. There is also a well-known story that Chaplin entered a contest for his own lookalikes and lost, but the official website judges it to be an unsupported invention.
The figure he had created was multiplying all over the world on its own. To me, the scene in the hall of mirrors, where neither the pursuing policeman nor the fleeing tramp can tell which is the real one, looked like that situation turned into laughter. On top of that, at this time Chaplin's divorce case meant that the newspapers were also writing whatever they liked about him (see the later section). I think the tramp, surrounded by mirrors and unable to find the way out, was also a picture of Chaplin himself at that time.
Filming began on 11 January 1926. Chaplin was thirty-six, and the year before he had just had a great success with The Gold Rush.
At the Tryout, Why Is He Not Funny When He Tries to Be?
The film's central device lies in the tryout, where the ringmaster's plan goes wrong. Left to chance, the tramp has the audience roaring with laughter, yet when he is taught an act and tries to copy it, he is not funny at all. At the tryout, the sight of him awkwardly imitating the senior clowns' old, set routines made me almost embarrassed to watch.
Why is he not funny? A clue lies in an essay Chaplin himself wrote for an American magazine in 1918, called "What People Laugh At". According to a passage quoted on the official website, Chaplin wrote that a drunk who tries earnestly and with dignity to insist he is not drunk is funnier than a man who acts like a typical drunk. What makes people laugh, in other words, is the gap between what a person is earnestly trying to do and a reality that will not go the way he wants.
Seen this way, the film's device becomes clear. The audience first erupted when the tramp was genuinely running away from the policeman. Even after he becomes a property man, he is only trying, in deadly earnest, to carry the props he has been told to carry. That gap between "earnestness" and "failure" is what makes the audience laugh. At the tryout, however, he is trying from the start to "be funny". What is more, what he was told to copy were the company's old acts, which the audience had already begun to tire of. Because he is not failing while trying to do things properly, but trying to show a failure, no gap appears, and the audience falls silent.
On the left is the tryout, and on the right the property-man scenes. The more earnest the tramp is, the larger the gap between his intentions and a reality that will not cooperate, and the more the audience laughs. If he sets out to "be funny" from the start, no gap appears (a simplified diagram).
Since I came to Britain in 1989, at twenty-nine, to work in a Japanese restaurant, my place of work has changed many times. This scene seems to me to speak to every one of them. The more we aim for a reaction from others, trying to "make them laugh" or "be liked", the more we neglect the work that actually matters in front of us.
Here, let me turn to ancient Rome, about two thousand years ago. The word "circus" goes back to the Latin circus, meaning a circle or a ring. In Rome there was a huge stadium for chariot racing, the Circus Maximus. The satirical poet A satirical poet of ancient Rome, active from the late first century to the early second century (his exact dates are uncertain). He is known for the line about "bread and circuses" in the tenth of his Satires., active from the late first century to the early second century, mocked the people of Rome, who had once had a say in politics, for now wanting only two things: bread (the handouts of food) and circuses (the shows at the stadium). Put another way, those at the top could avoid complaints as long as they kept the people's stomachs full and kept them entertained.
Taking bread and circuses as our clue, the way this film is built becomes clear. In Rome, those at the top gave the people both bread and circuses. In this film, however, both are in short supply. The tramp turns up at the fair hungry (no bread), and the company has lost the acts that make the audience laugh (no circus). So the poorest man of all, the tramp, becomes the one who delivers a circus, that is, laughter, to the company. Yet the bread he receives in return is very little. It is the opposite of Rome, and the one who gives the show is the hungriest of all. The American film critic Roger Ebert also wrote that what first brings the tramp and Merna together in this film is hunger, which always appears in Chaplin's work. The man who sells laughter is the hungriest of all. Once I knew about Chaplin's own poor childhood in London, this arrangement no longer looked like a coincidence to me.
Sharing Bread with Merna: What Did Two Hungry People Share?
The scene in which the tramp shares his food with Merna, who has been made to go without, was the quietest and warmest scene in the film. Both of them are hungry, yet each is thinking of the other's share. In the way he moves his hands, I saw the same tenderness that Chaplin showed the flower girl in City Lights.
An actress born in Illinois in 1908. A former dancer, she was cast as Chaplin's leading lady in The Circus on the recommendation of her friend Lita Grey. She retired in 1934 and died in 1944 at the age of thirty-six., who played Merna, had her first major role in this film. It is said that the person who recommended her to Chaplin was his wife at the time, Chaplin's second wife (1908–1995). She married him in 1924 while still in her teens and had two sons with him. At the end of 1926 she left home with their sons and sought a divorce, which was granted in August 1927., and that the two women were friends. It is also said that her legs, trained as a dancer, suited the role of a bareback rider (Wikipedia: Merna Kennedy).
What moved me most in this section was not so much the plot itself as the scene in which Merna tells the tramp that he is the one the audience comes to see. Until that day, the tramp had no idea that he had become the star of the company. It is hard to see our own worth for ourselves. Whether there is someone nearby who can tell us changes both how we work and how we live.
In the Lion's Cage, Why Is the Most Frightening Scene the Quietest?
The scene in which the tramp is shut in a lion's cage turns on one idea: if he makes a loud noise, the lion will wake up. Each time a small dog barks outside the cage, the tramp cringes without making a sound. Although it is a silent film, I found myself holding my breath during this scene.
The reason this scene can be called the quietest is that it makes its laughter in the opposite way to the other scenes. In this film, the laughter usually comes from movement. Running, falling, colliding, being chased. Inside the cage, however, moving or making a sound could be fatal. All the tramp can do is keep perfectly still. When we watch someone who cannot move, we too become unable to move, and we hold our breath along with him. That is why the most frightening scene is also the scene with the least movement, the quietest one.
What is more, the lion was real. According to the official Chaplin website, the lion scene was shot some two hundred times, and in many of those takes Chaplin was actually inside the cage. Perhaps the stiffness in the tramp's body on screen was not entirely acting.
Behind both this lion scene and the scenes in the tent, something was in fact going wrong at every stage of the filming. According to the official Chaplin website, the big tent was wrecked by gales before filming began. About a month after filming began, scratches were found on the film negative, and the footage shot so far could not be used. In September 1926 the studio caught fire, burning sets and props. From the end of that year into the start of the next, his wife Lita Grey sued for divorce, and her lawyers tried to seize the studio's assets. Chaplin is said to have secretly taken the footage already shot out of the studio and hidden it in a safe place. On top of this came the government's pursuit over unpaid taxes, and filming stopped for as long as eight months (Wikipedia).
To put the reason for the divorce suit in a word, a marriage that had never gone well from the start broke down in the most painful way. The two married in 1924, when Lita was still in her teens, and it is said that Chaplin stayed for long hours at the studio to avoid seeing his wife (Wikipedia: Charlie Chaplin). At the end of 1926 Lita left home with their two small sons, and in her suit, filed the following January, she listed in great detail her husband's relationships with other women and his heartless treatment of her. The text of the complaint was printed and circulated widely, and the newspapers wrote about Chaplin's private life day after day. The divorce was granted on 22 August 1927, and Chaplin paid more than 600,000 dollars, not counting funds held in trust for the sons. It is said to have been one of the largest divorce settlements of its time (Wikipedia: Lita Grey).
A circus tent under a stormy sky. For The Circus, too, the big tent is said to have been wrecked by gales before filming began.
Even so, the tramp on screen cringes in the cage as if nothing were wrong and makes the audience laugh. I thought that the ability to play the most frightening scene in the quietest way is the ability of someone who can concentrate on the one scene in front of him, even while a storm is blowing outside.
The Fortune-Teller's Words: Who Was the Man Merna Would Marry?
A fortune-teller tells Merna that she will soon marry a man close to her. Overhearing this from his hiding place, the tramp is sure that she means him. The contrast between the tramp, buying a ring with his heart swelling, and Rex, the tightrope walker who appears straight afterwards, was almost painful to watch.
One of the things that most unsettles the human heart is wanting something we cannot have. The tramp's feelings for Merna are exactly that. Yet Chaplin never turns this suffering into resentment, or into spite against Rex. Determined not to lose to Rex, the tramp secretly starts practising on the tightrope. Instead of pulling someone else down, he turns what he seeks and cannot have into practice of his own. I felt that this is where the tramp's decency lies.
I myself feel that my role has changed since I entered my sixties. Since I retired, I have been living while asking myself every day, "What am I going to do? What should I do to be of use?"
On the Tightrope, Why Does It Become a True Act Only Once the Safety Rope Comes Off?
Sent up onto the wire in Rex's place, the tramp crosses it proudly, relying on a safety rope hidden at his waist. Halfway across, however, the rope comes loose, and then monkeys that have escaped from their cage cling to him, pull down his trousers and bite his face. The moment he realises the rope has come off, the laughter vanishes from the tramp's face, and from then on it becomes a tightrope walk with his life truly at stake. At the length and height of this scene, I cried out in front of the screen again and again.
Thin lines strung across the sky. Seen from below, a tightrope is just as thin a single line.
So was this tightrope walk really filmed? According to the official Chaplin website, Chaplin and Harry Crocker, who played Rex, spent weeks learning the skills of tightrope walking. An article by the American film channel TCM also says that Chaplin actually learnt to walk the wire for this scene, that no camera tricks were used to make it look high, and that he never fell. It also says that, because of the damaged negative, about a month's worth of footage of the tightrope scene had to be scrapped and shot again. The three small monkeys that cling to the tramp on the wire were real too.
However, I could find no reliable record of whether, during the actual filming, there was a hidden safety line or a net below, separate from the safety rope in the film. Roger Ebert guessed that camera angles disguised the height and that there must have been a net (his review). So I cannot go so far as to say that "he filmed it at the risk of his life". What is certain is that he practised for weeks and walked the high wire on his own feet. Though it was a comedy from the outside, for Chaplin himself the days went on like the wire after the safety rope had come off. Filming stopped, the court case went on and the newspapers wrote what they liked, yet he still took the next step. Perhaps the tightrope walk after the safety rope comes off was Chaplin himself at that time.
In our sixties, the safety ropes of a company title and a salary come off one by one. Even so, the wire still goes on after the safety rope is gone. Living while asking myself every day what I should do to be of use, I begin to feel that the question itself is a way of looking for the next step on the wire.
[Spoilers: the Ending of the Film] What Was Left in the Ring After the Company Had Gone?
The following section discusses the ending of the film.
After the tightrope act, the tramp stands up to the ringmaster, who is beating Merna, and is thrown out of the company. Merna runs away from home and comes to the tramp. Keeping his own feelings to himself, the tramp finds Rex and has him marry Merna. Once the ringmaster learns that Merna has become Rex's wife, he can no longer lay a hand on her. Merna asks that the tramp come with them too, and the company is ready to take him in. Yet the tramp does not climb onto the departing line of wagons, and chooses to stay behind.
The wagons leave, and all that remains on the grass is the round mark where the tent stood. The tramp sits down in the middle of the ring, picks up a paper star lying there, gazes at it for a while, then crumples it and kicks it behind him. Then he stands up and walks off down the road with a slightly bouncing step.
I believe this round mark has something to do with the title. As I wrote in the section on the tryout, the word "circus" goes back to a Latin word meaning a circle or a ring. After the company had gone, what remained on the grass was exactly that "ring". When the tent, the band and the audience have all gone, the circus returns to the original form of its name, a simple circle. What is more, the film ends with the silent-film technique called the "iris", in which a black circle closes in from the edges of the screen, enclosing the back of the tramp as he walks away within a small circle (Roger Ebert's review). I could find no record of how far Chaplin intended this. Even so, when I watched it again, thinking of it as a film that begins with the "ring" of its title and ends with the mark of a ring and a closing circle, the last few minutes felt all the deeper.
A single road stretching far away across the grassland. Even after the company has gone, the road still goes on.
The biographer Jeffrey Vance points out that this final scene was shot four days after An American film released in New York in October 1927. Its star, Al Jolson, sings and also speaks a few short lines, and it is regarded as the start of the era of the talking film. opened in New York. It was the very first week in which films found a voice and began to talk. Vance reads the ending, with the company gone and the tramp left alone in the empty ring, as a picture of Chaplin's own position in the cinema, and he writes that Chaplin used "Blue Skies", a cheerful popular song made famous by Jolson, played slowly and sorrowfully, like a funeral dirge (Wikipedia, citing Vance).
After learning this and thinking back on the ending, the tramp's back as he sits in the mark of the ring looked completely different to me. What was leaving may have been not only the company but the age of silent film itself, in which he had been king. Even so, the tramp does not chase after it and does not resent it, but sets off with a light step.
Watching the tramp sit in the ring after the company had gone, what I, who retired from work at sixty-five, thought of was not loneliness but that light step.
Outside the Film: Why Did Chaplin Never Mention This Film in His Autobiography?
In 1964 Chaplin published a long autobiography. Yet of all the features of his mature years, The Circus alone is never once mentioned by name. The official Chaplin website also points this out. On its release it was well reviewed and did well at the box office, and in 1932 the American trade paper Variety listed it among its "biggest money pictures", with a total of 3,800,000 dollars. And yet for some forty years Chaplin kept this film largely out of sight (DVD Journal's review). The Gold Rush, made three years earlier, for example, was re-released in 1942 with Chaplin's own narration and new music. He brought an old work back to life to suit the age of films with sound. With The Circus, however, he did not do the same. In 1947 the composer Hanns Eisler worked on music for this film, but no version using it was released (he later reused the music in his Septet No. 2, "Circus") (Wikipedia). It was only in December 1969, in New York, that The Circus finally returned to cinemas with music Chaplin had composed himself.
The reason is not clear. Many critics believe that his memories of the filming were so painful that he did not want to speak about that whole period (for example, Roger Ebert and DVD Journal's review). The brighter the tramp looks in the film, the more I could not help thinking of the weight of the days behind it.
A timeline of The Circus. A fire and a divorce suit came in the middle of filming, and for some forty years after its release the film was hardly seen. The theme song he sang himself at seventy-nine dates from the 1969 re-release.
His mother Hannah died in August 1928, a little under eight months after the film's release. Some accounts count her death among the misfortunes during the filming, but when the dates are lined up, he lost his mother after the film had come out. As I wrote in the article on The Great Dictator, Chaplin later gave the young woman of the Jewish quarter the same name as his mother, Hannah. The joy of the release and the grief of losing his mother came in the same year.
At the The first awards ceremony, held at a Hollywood hotel on 16 May 1929. The award was not yet called the "Oscar". Chaplin was removed from the list of nominees and instead received a special award for The Circus. on 16 May the following year, 1929, Chaplin was removed from the nominations for Best Actor and other categories, and instead received a special award for the versatility he showed in writing, acting in, directing and producing The Circus on his own. It was Chaplin's first Academy Award.
The theme song I wrote about in the opening section was made for this 1969 re-release, and was sung by Chaplin himself at seventy-nine. He returned a film he had kept hidden to the world, adding his own voice to it. I imagine that it was work through which he was at last making peace with himself in that painful time.
How the Circus Took Root in Britain and Japan
Looking into it, I found that the modern form of the circus, in which many acts are shown at once inside a round ring, was born in Britain. It is said to have begun in April 1768, when A British showman (1742–1814). He joined a cavalry regiment at seventeen and rose to sergeant major. In 1768 he began staging shows of trick riding inside a round ring in London, and he is called the father of the modern circus., a former sergeant major of a cavalry regiment, began showing trick riding inside a round ring in a field near what is now Waterloo Station in London. He is said to have chosen a ring because, when a horse runs in a circle, centrifugal force makes it easier for a rider standing on its back to keep their balance. The size of the ring was later standardised at 42 feet (about 13 metres) across, and it is still the standard size of a circus ring today (Wikipedia). The "circle" of ancient Rome became a "ring" once again in London more than fifteen hundred years later.
In Japan, too, there had been shows of trick riding and acrobatics since the Edo period. But it was usual to form a troupe for each type of act, and the Western circus, which showed many acts on a single stage, astonished the people of the Meiji era. Around 1871 the French Soulié troupe is said to have performed at the Shokonsha in Kudan, Tokyo (now Yasukuni Shrine), and in 1886 the Italian A circus of horsemanship led by the Italian Giuseppe Chiarini. It came to Japan in 1886 and performed in Yokohama, Tokyo, Osaka and elsewhere. It is said to have been the first circus to perform before the Emperor Meiji. played to full houses in Kanda Akihabara. The Emperor Meiji is said to have attended as well, and in December of the same year Kawatake Mokuami wrote a kabuki play based on this circus, Narihibiku Charine Kyokuba, which Onoe Kikugoro V staged. The first circus later formed by Japanese performers borrowed the name and called itself the "Japan Chiarini Troupe". The Edo period (1603–1868) was the age of the Tokugawa shoguns, and the Meiji era (1868–1912) the age in which Japan opened to the West. Kawatake Mokuami (1816–1893) was the leading kabuki playwright of the late Edo and Meiji periods, and Onoe Kikugoro V (1844–1903) one of the great kabuki actors of the Meiji era.
Britain gave birth to the "ring" of the circus, and Japan took it into its own stage, kabuki. Chaplin grew up on the stages of London's music halls and carried that art into American film. To me, as I move with the seasons from Britain to Japan and from Japan to Britain, stories of an art crossing borders and changing its form do not feel like someone else's story.
Three Views on a Rich Later Life, and Some Closing Thoughts
How does watching films help a life that keeps mind and body in good order? A silent film cannot be watched while doing something else. With no spoken words, I cannot take my eyes off the actors' faces and hands, and for some seventy minutes there is no room to think about anything else. After watching The Circus, the chatter in my head stayed quiet for a while, and I even felt lighter in body.
Is there a reason to keep doing it, even when it costs money? This time I could watch it within my Prime membership, and in the UK there is also a free streaming service. What it cost me was time rather than money. Even so, I wanted to watch the seventy minutes made nearly a hundred years ago by one man in the hardest period of his life, even if it meant putting other things off for a while. What money buys is only the right to stream it, and what we take from it depends on what is in the life of the person watching.
New encounters. My greatest encounter this time was an actress called Merna Kennedy. She shone just once, in The Circus, and died at thirty-six. Through watching one film, I came to know the short life of someone whose name I had not even known. Each time I continue the series, the people who were around Chaplin take on faces in my mind, one by one.
To have someone tell us our own worth, which we cannot see ourselves, as Merna did. To take the next step on the wire, even after the safety rope has come off. And, after the company has gone, not to stay sitting in the mark of the ring, but to set off down the road with a light step. The Circus was a film about how to walk the second half of life, in the form of a film about laughter. Morning comes even to the grass after the company has gone. To anyone who is sitting in the mark of such a ring now, may a morning come, quietly, when you feel like standing up.
Next in the series, I plan to watch The Kid (1921), the story of the tramp who takes in an abandoned baby and brings him up.
A Word from Claude
The tramp became the star of the company without knowing that he was the one making the audience laugh. I, too, cannot confirm from the inside whether the sentences I write have reached anyone's heart. All I know is that writing the one sentence in front of me accurately seems to reach people better than straining to reach them.
Watching and Reading The Circus
As of October 2026, the subtitled version of The Circus can be rented on Amazon Prime Video in Japan for 400 yen, and it is also streaming on U-NEXT. In the UK, you can watch it with Prime Video at no extra cost. For readers in Japan who would like their own copy, it is also available on Blu-ray.
Watch The Circus on Prime Video
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
To deepen your understanding of the film, here are Chaplin's own autobiography and a detailed biography of his life and work.
For Chaplin's story in his own words (as I wrote above, this book never mentions The Circus):
Charles Chaplin, My Autobiography (Penguin Modern Classics), Kindle Edition
Charles Chaplin, My Autobiography (Penguin Modern Classics), Paperback
For a detailed, well-regarded biography of Chaplin's life and work:
David Robinson, Chaplin: His Life and Art (Penguin), Paperback
David Robinson, Chaplin: His Life and Art (Penguin), Kindle Edition
(As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.)
Other books you might like
You're welcome to take a look.
EAST TO WEST: The Heart of Haiku, the Light of Scripture
Words that cross a border take on a new form and put down roots in new soil. An essay that reads haiku and the Bible side by side. This is a book my father-in-law left behind.
View on AmazonCataract Surgery-A Memoir: Double cataract surgery in Osaka, Japan
A record of realising how precious sight is only after it began to fail. Some things about ourselves are hard to see for ourselves.
View on AmazonSushi Business in Britain: the complete four-volume series
A novel series following thirty-five years in the British sushi trade, from apprentice to factory manager to a small sushi school. The complete edition offers all four volumes at a better price.
Photo by Umanoide on Unsplash (tent under a stormy sky) / Photo by boris misevic on Unsplash (thin lines strung across the sky) / Photo by Mona Bernhardsen on Unsplash (road through grassland)